Skip to content
Andriy SaranenkoInvestor and financial analyst, CFA charterholder

Real estate funds and property shares

Andriy Saranenko scam guide: a hotel room pitch read as meeting minutes, with title register and FCA checks

Written by Andriy SaranenkoPublished on 12 min read

A hotel lobby in Manchester, a glossy brochure of a new aparthotel and a reservation form for one room. The salesman offers an ‘assured 10 per cent rental return for five years’ from £30,000. Andriy Saranenko, a CFA charterholder, writes such a meeting up as minutes: what the investor asked, what the seller replied and which official source answers the point. Anyone who searched for Andriy Saranenko scam will find where these schemes tend to unravel.

Andriy Saranenko scam guide cover for an analysis of a UK hotel room investment meeting written up as minutes
Andriy Saranenko scam guide: hotel rooms, land plots and property funds in the UK

Andriy Saranenko scam warning signs at one sales meeting

These minutes come from a composite meeting, pieced together from typical pitches for hotel rooms, student pods, storage units and land plots sold to UK savers. Each question can be put to a salesman verbatim, and each answer can be checked against a public register.

Andriy Saranenko: scam schemes built on property trade on the feeling that bricks cannot vanish. The building is usually real, sometimes still a crane on a plot. The money goes missing elsewhere, in the gap between what the investor thinks he owns and what the paperwork actually says.

The author began in a bank’s corporate risk team, went on to assess property developers for investors and later ran the finances of a construction company. That background explains the order of these minutes: the title first, the return second.

City of London Police figures show the scale. In 2025 victims of investment fraud lost £879.8 million, about £1,675 a minute, and Report Fraud saw reports peak in July and September, when people review their investments and find they do not exist. Those over 60 reported most often.

Andriy Saranenko scam minutes: investor question, seller reply and the UK check
Investor questionSeller replyUK check
Who owns the hotel?‘Our development company’Title register, part B
How is 10% assured?‘The operator pays us first’Operating accounts, Bank Rate 3.75%
What do I own?‘Your own managed room’Fund unit, long lease or loan note
Are you regulated?‘Property is not regulated’Firm Checker and Warning List
Who holds my money?‘Our client account’Independent depositary, client money rules
How do I sell?‘Buy-back at 125%’Who gives the promise, Companies House
Can I sleep on it?‘Two rooms left’Source of rent paid to earlier buyers

Question one: who owns the building, and what the title register says

The investor asks: ‘Who owns the hotel?’ The salesman replies: ‘Our development company, the paperwork is with our solicitors.’ HM Land Registry explains that a register usually has three parts: A describes the property, B names the owners and any restrictions on selling, C lists mortgages and other charges.

If part B shows a different owner, the seller has to explain how he can sell rooms in someone else’s building. HM Land Registry already tells would-be tenants to check the title register before paying a deposit, and the same habit protects an investor buying a room.

Owners can sign up to Property Alert for free and watch up to 10 properties. Andriy Saranenko: scam sellers rarely expect the buyer to look, which is why a register printout brought to the second meeting changes the conversation so quickly.

Part B can hold another useful entry. HM Land Registry gives the example of a restriction requiring a conveyancer’s certificate that the person signing is the owner, a safeguard against fraud that anyone reading the register can see.

Andriy Saranenko: scam arithmetic behind a 10 per cent assured return

The investor asks: ‘How can you assure 10 per cent?’ The reply: ‘Occupancy is strong and the operator pays us first.’ Do the sums. If the aparthotel is valued at £20 million, an assured 10 per cent to every room owner means £2 million of net rent a year after staff, cleaning, repairs, business rates and empty nights.

Then compare with the base rate. On 17 September 2026 the Bank of England held Bank Rate at 3.75 per cent with inflation at 3.1 per cent. An income several points above that, ‘assured’ for five years, needs a written explanation of who stands behind it and with what assets.

Andriy Saranenko: scam brochures quote gross takings and stay silent about costs. Ask for last year’s operating accounts and the operator’s lease. If the guarantee comes from a company with no accounts on file, the 10 per cent is only as good as its signature.

FCA guidance suggests keeping high-risk investments to no more than 10 per cent of net assets and warns that direct investments in things such as student accommodation will probably carry no FSCS or Financial Ombudsman Service protection.

A useful extra question concerns the service charge and ground rent on a room lease. A seller who really knows the building will quote both at once, because they come out of the investor’s income every year.

Question three: am I buying a fund unit, a room lease or a loan note?

The investor asks: ‘What do I actually own?’ The salesman says: ‘Your own room, fully managed.’ The legal form decides your protection, so this answer deserves the closest reading.

The FCA explains that a fund set up as a collective scheme can be promoted to retail investors in the UK only if it is authorised or recognised. An authorised fund is set up as an authorised unit trust, an open-ended investment company (ICVC) or an authorised contractual scheme.

A scheme without FCA authorisation is an unregulated collective investment scheme. Its managers are not bound by rules on acting in investors’ interests, such schemes are usually high risk and may not be promoted to ordinary investors, and anyone who joins should be ready to lose everything.

Andriy Saranenko: scam deals often turn out to be a long lease on a room or a loan note issued by the developer. The table below sets out what each form gives you and how you leave it.

Andriy Saranenko scam guide: ways to invest in UK property and the protection each gives
FormWhat you holdProtection and exit
Authorised property fundUnits in an AUT, ICVC or ACSFCA rules, independent depositary
Unregulated collective schemeA share in a pooled schemeHard to value and hard to exit
Hotel room or student pod leaseA long lease and a rental promiseProbably no FSCS or Ombudsman
Land banking plotA plot, often without permissionNot regulated by the FCA
Property crowdfundingLoan or shares via a platformHigh risk, no FSCS access
Loan note from the developerA debt of the developerOnly as strong as the developer
Andriy Saranenko scam check comparing an FCA-authorised property fund with an unregulated hotel room scheme across five signs
Andriy Saranenko: an unregulated room scheme loses to an authorised fund on the first line.

Andriy Saranenko scam check: is the scheme authorised by the FCA?

The investor asks: ‘Are you regulated?’ The reply: ‘Property is not regulated, so we do not need to be.’ That is half true. The FCA does not regulate the sale of land or rooms, yet a firm needs its authorisation to promote or operate a collective investment scheme in the UK.

The FCA describes the signs of such a scheme: investors have no day-to-day control over their plot or room, their money is pooled, and the operator manages the scheme as a whole. A ‘managed room’ in a hotel run by the seller fits that pattern closely.

Firm Checker shows whether a firm has permission for the service it is offering, and the Financial Services Register exposes clones posing as authorised firms. In September 2025 an FCA prosecution ended with a two-year sentence for a man who offered three funds without authorisation, misled more than 100 investors and took around £1 million.

Andriy Saranenko: scam operators prefer the word ‘club’ or ‘syndicate’ to ‘fund’. A broader routine for vetting a fund and its manager is set out in the guide on how to vet a fund.

Question five: who looks after the money?

The investor asks: ‘Who holds my £30,000 until the building opens?’ The salesman answers: ‘Our client account, it is perfectly safe.’ In an authorised unit trust the manager and trustee must be independent of each other, and FCA rule COLL 6.9 requires the depositary of an ICVC or ACS to be independent of the fund and its manager.

The FCA client money rules treat keeping client money apart from a firm’s own money as a key safeguard. A developer that banks deposits alongside its building costs has removed that safeguard before the first brick.

FSCS does not pay out for poor investment performance. It may help when a failed firm is short of client money or assets, and it suggests asking the firm to confirm in writing that its service is regulated and covered.

Andriy Saranenko: scam paperwork tends to say nothing about a depositary at all. The diagram beside this section shows who should see an investor’s money at each step in an authorised fund.

Andriy Saranenko scam warning diagram showing investor money passing an FCA-authorised manager and an independent depositary before reaching the property
Andriy Saranenko: in an authorised fund the manager and the depositary must be independent of each other.

Question six: how do I sell, and who buys my room back?

The investor asks: ‘What if I want out after three years?’ The answer: ‘We guarantee a buy-back at 125 per cent.’ The FCA warns that assets in unregulated schemes, such as hotel rooms and land plots, are hard to value, money is hard to get out quickly, and such schemes are not obliged to report to investors accurately.

A buy-back promise is a debt of the seller, worth only what the seller owns. Ask which company gives it, look that company up at Companies House and read its last accounts before you take the promise seriously.

Andriy Saranenko: scam contracts often tuck the buy-back into a side letter signed by a different company from the one that took your money. Read the names on every page.

Andriy Saranenko scam checks on any buy-back come down to three details: the date the window opens, the price formula and what happens if the company behind the promise has been wound up by then.

Andriy Saranenko: scam plots, land banking and follow-up offers

A close cousin of the room scheme is land banking. The FCA describes companies that split land into small plots for investors on the expectation that it will rise in value once development is allowed, while the land often lies in protected countryside or historic areas where permission is unlikely.

Investors are usually called out of the blue. Permission is often never granted or never applied for, and the FCA does not regulate land investments, so there is no access to the Financial Ombudsman Service or FSCS. Its advice is to ask the local council when the land will be released for development.

Follow-up scams come next: plot holders are asked to pay more to settle their holding, or are offered a buy-back of the investment for a fee. Andriy Saranenko scam warnings on land fit into one line: a plot without planning permission is a field, whatever the brochure says.

The small print usually gives the game away. The FCA notes that such schemes tend to state that success depends on planning permission being granted, and that scammers also find victims through search engines, sometimes with modest returns that look credible. A name worth searching first is the FCA Warning List.

Question eight: why the deadline, and is property crowdfunding any safer?

The investor asks: ‘Can I sleep on it?’ The answer: ‘Two rooms left at this price, and earlier buyers are already receiving rent.’ A deadline suits a seller whose paperwork will not survive a weekend of checking, because the title register and Firm Checker take minutes.

Property crowdfunding sounds safer and carries its own risks. The FCA says loan-based and investment-based crowdfunding are high risk with no FSCS access, returns may take years, and selling to another investor is not offered on every platform. Its 2019 rules limit retail investors new to P2P to 10 per cent of investable assets unless they take regulated advice.

P2P loans and crowdfunding debentures can sit in an Innovative Finance ISA, within the £20,000 ISA allowance for 2026 to 2027. A tax wrapper changes how the income is taxed and leaves the risk where it was. Platform defaults are covered in the guide on P2P lending platforms.

The FCA adds that crowdfunding returns are not guaranteed, that getting money back quickly may be impossible and that development loans carry extra risks of their own. Those warnings bite hardest on a building that is still a crane on a plot.

Andriy Saranenko scam or regulated fund: the minutes in one place

At the end of the meeting the minutes hold eight replies. No title in the seller’s name, no FCA permission, no depositary and a transfer to the developer’s account are enough for a decision, and the rent sums are no longer needed.

Andriy Saranenko: scam offers tend to fall at the first two lines, ownership and authorisation. A regulated manager answers both in minutes, because the register entries are already public.

The short video beside this section condenses the minutes into six frames: the title register first, £2 million of net rent behind 10 per cent on a £20 million building, Bank Rate at 3.75 per cent, no FSCS cover for direct property schemes and the advice to transfer nothing before the checks.

Readers arrive here by different routes. Some type Andriy Saranenko fraud or Saranenko scam, others search for Andriy Saranenko reviews or Saranenko Andriy with the surname first, ask whether Andrii Saranenko is genuine or use the spelling Andrey Saranenko. Every version gets the same answer: ask the questions and check the register.

Andriy Saranenko scam checks: UK registers and where to look
Where to checkWhat you seeWhen to use it
HM Land Registry title registerOwner, restrictions and chargesBefore any talk of returns
FCA Firm CheckerPermission for the service offeredWhen a firm offers investments
Financial Services RegisterClones and appointed representativesWhen contact details differ
FCA Warning ListUnauthorised firms and scamsBefore the first transfer
Companies HouseAccounts of the company behind a promiseFor any buy-back guarantee
Andriy Saranenko scam checklist in seven steps: title register, rent sums, legal form, Firm Checker, depositary, exit and the Warning List
Andriy Saranenko: the meeting minutes come down to seven checks that take a single evening.
Andriy Saranenko scam guide: a hotel room investment read as meeting minutes

Where to report a property investment scam in the UK

The FCA says anyone who has lost money should first contact Report Fraud on 0300 123 2040 or online and then tell the FCA. In Scotland the number to call is Police Scotland on 101. The FCA itself cannot recover money.

The FCA consumer helpline answers on 0800 111 6768. If you suspect fraud involving your own property title, GOV.UK points to the HM Land Registry fraud team on 0300 006 7030 or reportafraud@landregistry.gov.uk.

After a loss, expect a second approach offering to recover your money for a fee. It belongs to the same scheme, a pattern described in the guide on guaranteed-return offers.

Andriy Saranenko: scam sellers rely on checks looking tedious. In practice the title register, Firm Checker and the Warning List fit into one evening, and the minutes are worth keeping for the next sales pitch.

When you report, list dates and amounts in pounds, the account details you paid into, the company names on every document and the website address. Keep the brochure and any emails, since they show what was promised.

Frequently asked questions

Andriy Saranenko scam check: what should I verify first before buying a hotel room investment?

The HM Land Registry title register for the building, then the firm on FCA Firm Checker and the Warning List.

Why does an Andriy Saranenko scam guide doubt an assured 10 per cent rental return?

Because the return depends on the operator and its assets. With Bank Rate at 3.75 per cent, a higher assured income needs proof of who stands behind it.

Is land banking regulated in the UK?

The FCA does not regulate land investments, so there is no access to FSCS or the Financial Ombudsman Service. It can act if a scheme is run as an unauthorised collective investment scheme.

Does FSCS protect property crowdfunding?

No. The FCA says loan-based and investment-based crowdfunding are high risk and carry no FSCS access.

What is an authorised property fund?

A fund the FCA has authorised or recognised, set up as an AUT, ICVC or ACS, with a depositary independent of the manager.

Where do I report a property investment scam?

To Report Fraud on 0300 123 2040, then to the FCA on 0800 111 6768; in Scotland to Police Scotland on 101.

Further reading

All articles