Skip to content
Andriy SaranenkoInvestor and financial analyst, CFA charterholder

P2P lending and crowdlending

Andriy Saranenko scam checks for UK peer-to-peer lending. No FSCS cover, the 10 per cent limit and clone platforms

Written by Andriy SaranenkoPublished on 12 min read

Andriy Saranenko scam guide to peer-to-peer lending in the UK: a CFA charterholder explains how the FCA describes loan-based crowdfunding, why lenders have no FSCS protection, what the 10 per cent limit for new investors means, how an Innovative Finance ISA changes the tax and leaves the risk in place, and how to check a platform before you send money.

Andriy Saranenko scam checks for UK peer-to-peer lending: cover of a guide to FCA rules and clone platforms
Andriy Saranenko scam checks: peer-to-peer lending in the UK, FCA rules

Andriy Saranenko: scam risks in UK peer-to-peer lending and the author

A graduate in finance and credit of Lviv Polytechnic National University, Andriy Saranenko passed all three CFA levels at his first attempt and was awarded the charter in 2016. He worked as a corporate risk analyst at a bank and later as chief financial officer of a construction company, where he led a full restructuring of its debt, and now runs private asset management and venture investment.

His Insights section reads financial offers the way a lender reads a loan application. Peer-to-peer lending deserves that treatment, because the product is a loan and its risk sits with whoever lends. In the view of Andriy Saranenko, scam offers in this market sell the opposite idea, that the platform carries the risk for you.

Anyone typing Andrey Saranenko or looking for fraud claims about lending sites is usually weighing a real offer. This guide therefore begins with the FCA's own description of crowdfunding and then turns to the warning signs.

No platforms are named or recommended. The aim is a routine any reader can apply, checked against what the FCA, GOV.UK and the police publish.

It is written for someone holding a real offer who wants to decide within an evening whether to send money. The Register, the Warning List and GOV.UK are all the tools that decision needs.

Loan-based crowdfunding as the FCA describes it

The FCA describes loan-based crowdfunding, also called peer-to-peer lending, as a service that connects people who want to borrow with people willing to lend. Lenders receive repayments over time, usually with interest, and the platform takes a fee.

Investment-based crowdfunding works differently: you buy shares or invest in business-backed loans, usually in small or medium-sized companies not yet listed on a stock market. The FCA calls both forms high-risk, and neither gives access to the Financial Services Compensation Scheme.

As explained by Andriy Saranenko, scam platforms rely on lenders who have never read that page. They describe a P2P loan as «like a savings account, only better», the one comparison the regulator's own wording rules out.

The FCA lists the practical risks plainly. You may lose all the money you invest if the company fails, returns are not guaranteed and can take years, and you may not get your money back quickly or at all.

Property development loans carry extra risks on the FCA's list: a project may never be completed or the loan may go unpaid, overseas legal systems may differ, and currency moves can cut returns.

Andriy Saranenko scam checks: types of crowdfunding in the UK and the main risk of each
TypeWhat the lender getsMain risk
Loan-based (peer-to-peer)Repayments with interestBorrower default, no FSCS
Investment-basedShares or business-backed loansCompany fails, money lost
Innovative Finance ISATax-free interest on P2P loansSame default risk
Clone of an authorised firmCopied name and numberMoney sent to fraudsters
Unauthorised «lending club»Promise of fixed incomeNo Ombudsman, no FSCS

Andriy Saranenko scam checks: FCA authorisation and the Warning List

The FCA advises dealing only with authorised firms, checking in Firm Checker that a firm has permission for the specific service, using only contact details shown on the Register and searching the FCA Warning List before any payment.

Firm Checker has limits. The FCA warns that it does not confirm FSCS or Financial Ombudsman Service protection will apply and does not show whether a firm may hold client money; those details sit on the Financial Services Register itself.

Andriy Saranenko scam checks add one more step: compare the firm's name, reference number and web address on the Register with those on the site you are using. The Warning List already holds clones of authorised firms that copied real details and changed only the contact route.

With an unauthorised firm you lose the route to the Financial Ombudsman Service and to FSCS compensation, the FCA says. Money sent to a clone goes to someone with no regulator behind them.

Repeat the search on the day of the transfer. A firm can lose its permission, and a clone can appear, in the weeks between a first call and a first payment.

Andriy Saranenko scam checks diagram comparing an FCA authorised P2P lending platform with a clone or unauthorised site in the UK
Andriy Saranenko scam checks for UK lenders: the Register and the Warning List answer most questions in minutes.

The 2019 rules: 10 per cent and the appropriateness check

On 4 June 2019 the FCA confirmed new rules for P2P platforms. Retail customers new to the sector are limited to investing 10 per cent of their investable assets in P2P agreements, unless they have received regulated financial advice.

Where no advice has been given, the platform must assess the investor's knowledge and experience of P2P investments. The rules also strengthened wind-down plans for platforms that fail and set out the minimum information investors must receive. Most changes applied from 9 December 2019.

In the experience of Andriy Saranenko, scam sites skip these questions entirely. A lending site that lets a first-time lender pour in savings with no assessment and no limit is ignoring the FCA's rulebook.

The FCA's guidance on high-risk investments suggests keeping them to no more than 10 per cent of total net assets. Both figures point the same way: P2P money should be money you can afford to lose.

A genuine assessment can feel like an obstacle. It is also the clearest sign that the platform follows the rules written for it.

Andriy Saranenko scam checks diagram of how a UK lender's money moves through a P2P platform to borrowers without FSCS cover
Andriy Saranenko scam checks: loan-based crowdfunding has no FSCS cover, so the platform and the borrower carry all the weight.

Andriy Saranenko: scam maths behind 20 to 30 per cent a year

A high rate on a loan to a small business is not suspicious in itself. The borrower pays more because lending to it is riskier, and the lender is paid for taking that risk.

Compare the promise with protected savings. FSCS automatically covers up to 120,000 pounds per person per bank, building society or credit union authorised by the PRA, and none of that protection reaches a P2P loan.

According to Andriy Saranenko, scam adverts present 25 or 30 per cent as «steady income», when a rate that high is the market pricing in a real chance of default.

The FCA notes that in Ponzi and pyramid schemes early members may make money while later ones usually lose it, so payouts that never vary deserve suspicion. The same pattern of returns fixed in advance appears in the guide Andriy Saranenko wrote on guaranteed-yield offers.

Ask the platform for its record of late payments over past years and how it calculates the figure. A reply of «nobody has ever lost money with us» says more about the seller than about the loans.

Default risk: Andriy Saranenko on a ten-loan example

Spread 6,000 pounds across ten loans of 600 pounds at 25 per cent a year. Nine borrowers repay with interest, each bringing 150 pounds, 1,350 pounds in all. The tenth repays nothing and 600 pounds are lost. The year ends 750 pounds ahead, a return of 12.5 per cent.

Two defaults in ten cancel the year's interest altogether, and a single loan that takes the whole sum can lose all of it.

Andriy Saranenko scam warnings follow from this sum: a misleading pitch quotes the best loan and never shows the portfolio after a default. Ask how the platform pursues late payers, who bears the legal costs and what lenders receive if a borrower is wound up.

The FCA points to a second problem. Some platforms let you sell a loan to another investor after a delay, not all of them offer this, and a sale may not return all of your money.

No platform can promise that ten borrowers will behave like the average. One bad year in a single sector can hit several loans at once, so concentration matters as much as the headline rate.

Andriy Saranenko scam maths: what defaults do to ten P2P loans in pounds
ScenarioResult for the yearReturn
Ten 600-pound loans at 25 per cent, all repaid1,500 pounds25 per cent
One borrower in ten repays nothing750 pounds12.5 per cent
Two borrowers in ten repay nothing0 pounds0 per cent
All 6,000 pounds in one loan that defaultsMinus 6,000 poundsTotal loss

Andriy Saranenko: scam talk of reserve funds and guarantees

No platform can turn a loan into a protected deposit. The FCA says plainly that loan-based crowdfunding gives no access to FSCS, so any promise of «capital protection» rests on the platform's own resources.

In the view of Andriy Saranenko, scam sites borrow banking vocabulary: «insured», «reserve fund», «guaranteed by our partner». Each word needs a document showing who provides the protection, for how much, under which contract and where that provider appears on the Register.

Ask too what happens if the platform itself fails. The 2019 rules required stronger wind-down plans, and an authorised platform should be able to explain in writing who would keep collecting repayments.

A guarantee that nobody can check is marketing copy, however reassuring it sounds on the phone.

Look for the protection wording in the loan agreement itself. Wording that lives only in adverts and chat messages binds nobody.

Innovative Finance ISA: a tax wrapper with the same risk

GOV.UK lists peer-to-peer loans and crowdfunding debentures among the investments an Innovative Finance ISA can hold. In the 2026 to 2027 tax year you can put up to 20,000 pounds into ISAs, and the tax year runs from 6 April to 5 April.

The wrapper shelters interest from tax. It changes nothing when a borrower defaults, and the 10 per cent logic still applies to the size of the holding.

As noted by Andriy Saranenko, scam offers like the phrase «ISA-approved», as if the label were a seal of safety. An ISA is a tax status, and a fake platform can print the letters as easily as a logo.

If an ISA manager is involved, confirm on the Register that it is authorised and that the account opened is in your name, with the manager shown on every statement.

Keep every annual statement from the ISA manager. If a dispute arises, they show what you held, when and with whom.

Andriy Saranenko scam checks before the first transfer

Start with the Financial Services Register and confirm the firm's permission for the service. Then search the FCA Warning List for its name and for anything that looks similar.

Next, make sure money only moves to the platform's own accounts named in its terms, never to a personal account or a crypto wallet. Expect the platform to ask about your knowledge, experience and the share of your assets you plan to lend.

Read every rate together with the default risk and ignore talk of guarantees. Lend only what you could lose without harm. Andriy Saranenko scam screening usually stops a bad offer at the first or third check.

If any check fails, wait a week. A genuine offer will still be there, and a payment to a fraudster is far harder to recover.

Save dated screenshots of each check. If the site later rewrites its pages, you still hold a record of what it promised when you lent.

Andriy Saranenko scam checks list with six steps before lending through a peer-to-peer platform in the United Kingdom
Andriy Saranenko scam checks: an offer that fails the first or third step does not need the others.

Where P2P lending sits in a portfolio

P2P loans pay only when businesses pay, and money can stay tied up for years. That rules them out as an emergency fund and limits them to a small slice of long-term savings.

Andriy Saranenko scam analysis starts from one question: if this loan went to zero, would the household feel it? If yes, the amount is too large, however solid the borrower appears.

Savings clubs and credit-union look-alikes raise similar questions, covered in Andriy Saranenko's guide to credit union savings. For the people behind an offer, the guide on checking a financier against official registers sets out the steps.

In 2025, 34,673 people told Report Fraud about investment fraud, a rise of 31 per cent on the year before; losses reached 879.8 million pounds, about 25,612 pounds per victim on average.

Spreading money across many small loans softens the blow of one failure without removing the risk, and each extra loan adds another set of documents to follow.

Reporting a lending scam in the UK

Report Fraud took over from Action Fraud on 4 December 2025 and kept the number 0300 123 2040; online reports go to reportfraud.police.uk. If money left your account recently, call your bank straight away on the number on the back of your card.

Tell the FCA about an unauthorised platform or a clone through its website, and keep the Register entry of the genuine firm as evidence that the site you dealt with was a copy.

Per Andriy Saranenko, scam reports work best when they are precise: dates, sums in pounds, the platform's name and web address, the names its staff used and the account that received the money.

Treat any later offer to recover your money for a fee as a second attempt, and report that contact too. Searches for Saranenko Andriy on this topic lead back to the same routine.

Note the sequence while you remember it: the first contact, each payment and the day the platform went quiet. That sequence helps the police connect your report with others.

Andriy Saranenko scam reporting: where to go in the UK
SituationWhere to goContact
Money lost to a lending platformReport Fraud0300 123 2040
Payment sent in the last hoursYour bankNumber on your card
Clone of an authorised firmFCAWarning List and website
Firm's permission in doubtFCAFinancial Services Register
Offer to recover lost moneyReport Fraudreportfraud.police.uk

Frequently asked questions

Andriy Saranenko scam checks: is peer-to-peer lending covered by FSCS?

No. The FCA says loan-based and investment-based crowdfunding are high-risk and give no access to the Financial Services Compensation Scheme.

Andriy Saranenko scam warning: how do I spot a clone lending platform?

Compare the name, reference number and web address on the Financial Services Register with the site, and search the FCA Warning List before paying.

How much can a new investor put into P2P loans?

Under FCA rules from 2019, retail customers new to P2P are limited to 10 per cent of investable assets unless they have received regulated advice.

Does an Innovative Finance ISA make P2P lending safer?

It shelters interest from tax. GOV.UK lists peer-to-peer loans among its contents, and the default risk stays exactly the same.

Can I sell a P2P loan early?

Some platforms allow a sale to another investor after a delay, the FCA says, not all do, and you may not recover all of your money.

Where does Andriy Saranenko suggest reporting a lending scam in the UK?

To Report Fraud on 0300 123 2040 or reportfraud.police.uk, to your bank straight away, and to the FCA about unauthorised firms or clones.

Further reading

All articles