Skip to content
Andriy SaranenkoInvestor and financial analyst, CFA charterholder

AI trading bots

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks: AI trading robots. How to test a robo-trading presentation in the UK

Written by Andriy SaranenkoPublished on 14 min read

A ten-slide presentation promises that an AI trading robot will deal for you and return 8 per cent a month. Andriy Saranenko, a financial analyst and CFA charterholder, works through it as an investor would: sums in pounds, a question for every slide and a check against the FCA register. Readers who arrived by searching “Andriy Saranenko fraud” will see where such a deck hides the catch and what to ask before sending anything.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks: AI trading robots and FCA checks in the UK

Andriy Saranenko: fraud warnings about trading robots and the deck under review

Andriy Saranenko trained in finance at Lviv Polytechnic, has held the CFA charter since 2016, and has worked as a bank risk analyst and as finance director of a property developer. Since 2023 he has managed private assets and made venture investments.

In Britain these robots are usually sold through social media adverts, finfluencers and messaging groups. Andriy Saranenko: fraud of this sort runs to a fixed script, so the presentation reviewed here is a composite of standard slides, and no real firm is named.

Every slide faces three questions: what is promised, what would have to be true for the promise to hold, and which UK record shows it. When no record shows it, the slide is marketing.

Software that places trades by fixed rules is perfectly lawful. The problem arrives with a promised return, a wallet you do not control and a reward for bringing in friends. Anyone who typed “Saranenko Andriy fraud” or “Andriy Saranenko scam” will find worked sums and a one-evening check below, as will anyone who used the Russian spelling “Andrey Saranenko fraud”.

The same review is sometimes searched under other spellings, such as “Andrii Saranenko”. Whatever the spelling, the method stays the same: every promise is tested against a sum and a public register.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud in a robot presentation fails six questions put to the seller in writing.

Slide 1. “A neural network does the trading”

The word AI on a cover tells you nothing about a strategy. The US derivatives regulator, the CFTC, reminded customers in 2024 that artificial intelligence cannot predict the future or sudden market moves, while fraudsters claim such algorithms return tens of thousands of per cent.

The FCA does not keep a separate category for AI robots. It adds individual firms to its Warning List, and names with AI and bot trading in them appear there regularly. One such entry from May 2023 carries the standard note that the firm may be offering financial services without FCA authorisation.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud dressed as AI skips the main question, what the model actually does. Without a description of the market, the entry and exit rules and the responsible firm, AI is a sticker.

The opposite also happens: a real firm, an invented AI. In March 2024 the SEC penalised two American advisers for false claims about using artificial intelligence and called the practice AI washing.

A joint alert from the SEC, NASAA and FINRA in January 2024 quoted the sort of line these covers use, a proprietary AI system that “can't lose”, and described guaranteed high returns at little risk as a classic sign of fraud.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks slide by slide: what a trading robot presentation promises and UK checks
SlidePromiseUK check
1. CoverA neural network tradesWho runs the model and what it trades
2. Returns8 per cent a monthA factor of 2.52 a year, weighed against risk
3. BacktestA curve without dipsPeriod, charges, worst drawdown
4. ReviewsProfit screenshotsA statement from an authorised firm
5. APIFive minutes to linkKey permissions without withdrawals
6. RentalShared pool or subscriptionPounds stay in your account
7. Bonuses10, 5 and 3 per cent for recruitsWhere payouts come from
8. LicenceOffshore registrationFirm Checker and the FRN
9 and 10. ExitAny time, few places leftA small test withdrawal

Andriy Saranenko: fraud maths behind 8 per cent a month

Do the sum. Eight per cent a month compounds to a factor of 2.52 over a year. A £5,000 deposit would have to reach about £12,590 after one year and roughly £79,840 after three.

For that to be true, the robot would need to outperform every fund manager in the world for years on end without a losing month. Someone holding such a system would grow their own capital and would not sell subscriptions to strangers.

Turn it round. Four thousand clients with £5,000 each make £20 million under the robot, and 8 per cent a month means £1.6 million in payouts every month. If trading does not produce that, only new deposits can.

The FCA describes the typical pattern of online trading scams: small early returns, then a request to invest more or bring in friends, then payments stop and the account is blocked. Andriy Saranenko: fraud with steady percentages always uses the word stable, and real strategies have bad months.

A sanity check from the other side of the table: what would the seller earn by simply running the robot on a £100,000 account of their own? At 8 per cent a month, more than £150,000 in the first year. People with that kind of machine do not usually advertise on social media.

Slide 3. A three-year backtest and a curve without dips

A backtest replays a strategy's rules over past prices. Try hundreds of parameter settings on the same stretch of history and one of them will look superb by chance; that is the one that lands on the slide.

Signs of curve fitting: a single favourable period where five or ten years belong, no years with a market fall, no charges or spreads, no worst drawdown. Ask whether the rules were tested on data that played no part in setting them.

Charges in numbers. Twenty-five trades a day at 0.06 per cent each in commission and spread, twenty trading days: 500 trades, and 0.9994 to the power of 500 gives 0.74. Roughly 26 per cent of the deposit goes in costs within a month, and the slide usually shows none of it.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud avoids drawdowns because the maths is awkward. A 50 per cent fall needs a 100 per cent gain just to get back to where you started.

American advisers may show hypothetical performance only under the SEC Marketing Rule of December 2020, with procedures that make the figures relevant to the audience and with the assumptions disclosed. A UK investor can put the same request in writing: who ran the backtest, on which data and with which charges.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud sells a curve with no drawdowns, a verifiable report shows losses and charges.

Slide 4. Dashboard screenshots and thank-you notes

Screenshots prove nothing; a dashboard image takes a minute to fake. In a case described by the CFTC, the organiser built fake client balances on demonstration accounts of a trading platform, which look real and hold no money.

The FCA warned in October 2025 that finfluencers may not disclose that they promote unregulated offshore firms, some promising unrealistic returns to people who copy trades, invest in managed accounts or pay for daily tips. At one firm alone, more than 90,000 people lost around £75 million over four years.

The only evidence worth having is a statement for your own account from an authorised firm, downloaded by you. People who search “Andriy Saranenko reviews” about robots mostly find a wall of praise with no statements at all.

Dated complaints tell you more: the step at which withdrawals stopped, the fee requested, the stranger who offered help. Such stories repeat from scheme to scheme almost word for word.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud evidence in reviews is usually indirect. A statement worth trusting carries the authorised firm's name, your account number and the dates of every trade, and you can request it again from the firm itself.

Slide 5. “Link the robot to your account by API in five minutes”

An API key lets a program work with an account without the password. Its settings show whether it may only trade or may also withdraw funds, and that line is checked before anything is connected.

A trading robot never needs withdrawal rights, whatever the strategy. A request to switch them on, drop an address restriction or share a login means the access exists to move your money.

The FCA has reported that screen-sharing cases rose 86 per cent in a year to 2,014, with losses above £25 million. Callers posing as advisers ask victims to install AnyDesk, TeamViewer or similar software, and 85 per cent of investors surveyed would not see a request to download software as a warning sign.

Legitimate firms will not ask to see your screen. Andriy Saranenko: fraud through API access tends to end in a “technical error” that leaves the balance at someone else's address.

The FCA's own advice is blunt: never share passwords and never install software from untrusted sources, because it can hand someone else control of the device and every banking app on it.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud asks you to send pounds to the bot owner, a sound service leaves them in your account.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud with robot rentals and shared pools

The pricing slide shows who holds the pounds. A software subscription leaves your money in your own account. A transfer to a shared pool, a crypto wallet or a personal card hands it to the robot's owner with no management agreement at all.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud nearly always prefers the second option, because a pooled balance is easy to inflate on screen and easy to freeze.

Ask for the contract before paying anything. It should name the company supplying the software, explain how to cancel and state that client money never passes through the seller. A one-page “membership agreement” with an offshore address tells you the pool is the real product.

Rental in numbers: £150 a month on a £1,000 account means the robot must earn 15 per cent monthly just to cover the fee, which is £1,800 a year, nearly twice the deposit, before platform charges.

Managing someone else's money or advising on investments are regulated activities in the UK. The FCA's Firm Checker shows whether a firm has permission for that specific service and is updated within 24 hours on average; details about individuals are in the Financial Services Register.

Slide 7. Bonuses for recruits on three levels

The seventh slide offers 10, 5 and 3 per cent of what your recruits deposit. Together that is 18 per cent of every new deposit paid to recruiters before a single trade. Of £1,000, at most £820 reaches the robot.

In the case the American regulator described, members earned bonuses for referrals, and the scheme operated as a Ponzi: new money paid earlier members and the organiser kept the rest. Hardly any real trading took place.

The end is easy to forecast. A £2 million pool promising 8 per cent a month owes £160,000 every month. While inflows exceed payouts it looks healthy; once they slow, “maintenance” starts, and then contact stops.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud with referrals shows in the ratio. When recruiting pays better than the strategy, recruiting is the product.

Recruiting bonuses also turn early members into the scheme's sales force. Friends and relatives join on their word, so when payments stop the losses land inside one circle of people who trusted each other.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud with borrowed licences and team photos

Slide eight shows a “licence”, seals and smiling staff. The FCA advises checking a firm on the Warning List and in Firm Checker, comparing its FRN and contact details, and replying only through contacts listed there.

If a firm has no contact details on the register or calls them out of date, the FCA suggests ringing it on 0800 111 6768. Clone firms copy the names of authorised ones, so the email address and phone number matter as much as the name.

In 2026 the FCA added signal providers whose only listed contacts were Telegram, Facebook and Instagram, noting that customers of such firms have no access to the Financial Ombudsman Service or FSCS protection.

A domain registered last month beside a story of five profitable years answers the question on its own. Andriy Saranenko: fraud of this kind tends to show an offshore certificate with a grand crest and no UK record.

The American regulator, the CFTC, also suggests a reverse image search on the people shown as the team and a look at the domain's registration date at lookup.icann.org. Stock photos of “analysts” turn up quickly.

Slides 9 and 10. “Withdraw whenever you like” and “final places”

The ninth slide promises instant withdrawals. The first sizeable request meets a fee, a “tax”, a deposit or a frozen account. The FCA notes that after a loss, scammers may come back offering to recover the money for a fee.

Tax in the UK is settled with HMRC under its own rules, and a platform that collects “profit tax” through a support chat is collecting for itself.

Withdrawal fees are the moment most people finally search the firm's name. By then the useful step is to stop paying, keep the chat history and treat every new demand as part of the same scheme, however official the letterhead looks.

Slide ten adds a deadline: “final places”, “bonus ends Friday”. A quick defence against slide nine is a small test withdrawal to your own bank account before adding money; if a fee appears at that stage, it will only grow.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud hurries you because an unhurried evening of checks closes the sale. Before any payment that is meant to unlock a withdrawal, talk it through with someone you trust. Fraud works best on a person who has been told to keep the opportunity private.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks: a sound algorithmic service and a bait robot for UK readers
SignSound serviceBait
Promised returnA range with losing monthsThe same percentage every month
Where the pounds areAn account with an authorised firmPersonal card, wallet, pool
Account accessTrading-only keyPassword and AnyDesk
PermissionListed in Firm CheckerOffshore certificate
ReportingPlatform statementScreenshots and demo account
WithdrawalsTo your own bank accountTax, insurance, verification fees

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks: sound algorithmic service or bait

Begin with the firm: the exact name and FRN, Firm Checker, the Warning List. A firm absent from the Warning List is not thereby safe; the question is whether it holds permission for the service it offers.

Then the money. Ask in writing which authorised firm will hold the account, what permissions the key will have and where withdrawals will go. A pool, a wallet or a manager's card in the reply ends the discussion.

Finally the numbers: compounded annual return, cost per trade times the number of trades, the worst drawdown, the rental fee. How promises of guaranteed income are constructed is set out in the review on guaranteed yield, and the warning signs of a sham broker in the piece on forex dealers and bucket shops.

The documents for a decision are short: a contract naming the firm, its FRN, the platform holding the account and a sample statement from a live account. Without any one of them there is nothing to connect.

One evening spent this way costs nothing. Skipping it can cost the whole deposit, plus every fee paid afterwards in the hope of getting the first sum back.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks: UK registers and where to report a robot seller
Register or bodyWhat it showsWhen to use it
FCA Firm CheckerPermission for a specific serviceBefore opening an account
FCA Warning ListFirms operating without permissionBefore any transfer
Financial Services RegisterIndividuals and restrictionsWhen a named adviser calls
FCA consumer line 0800 111 6768Contact details of a firmIf the register lists none
Report Fraud, 0300 123 2040Crime reports and a referenceAfter a loss
Your bankPSR reimbursement claimStraight after a transfer to a fraudster

Andriy Saranenko: fraud already happened, where to report in the UK

Revoke API keys, remove remote access software, change passwords and ring your bank on the number printed on your card. Do it in that order, because a live key can keep moving money while you are on the phone.

Report the loss to the FCA and then to Report Fraud, which replaced Action Fraud on 4 December 2025, at reportfraud.police.uk or on 0300 123 2040. For transfers to a fraudster made on or after 7 October 2024, the PSR reimbursement rules may apply, so tell your bank promptly.

If an unauthorised firm approached you, tell the FCA on 0800 111 6768 or through its contact form, even if you sent no money. That is how firms reach the Warning List and how the next reader finds the warning.

During one week of joint action in April 2026, the FCA issued 34 warnings in the UK and flagged 1,267 illegal financial adverts, two thirds of them from firms and individuals on its Warning List.

Keep every message, wallet address and the presentation itself. If someone now offers to recover the money for a percentage, that is the second round of the same scheme, described in the piece on brokers who operate through messaging apps.

Frequently asked questions

Andriy Saranenko: fraud with AI trading robots, how do I check a seller in the UK?

Find the firm in Firm Checker by its exact name and FRN, check the Warning List and use only the contact details on the register. Send money only to an account in your own name.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks: what is wrong with a backtest on a slide?

It can be fitted to history. Look at the length of the period, charges, the worst drawdown and testing on fresh data; only a statement from a live account counts as evidence.

Can I give a robot an API key?

Only one that may trade and cannot withdraw. A request for your password or for screen sharing means the access is wanted for moving money.

What does 8 per cent a month mean over a year?

Around 152 per cent compounded: £5,000 would become about £12,590. No strategy produces that evenly.

What should I do if a platform wants a fee before a withdrawal?

Pay nothing. Revoke keys, call your bank and report to the FCA and to Report Fraud on 0300 123 2040.

Where does Andriy Saranenko suggest UK readers report a robot?

To the FCA, which can add the firm to its Warning List, and to Report Fraud at reportfraud.police.uk.

Further reading

All articles