Fund fees over ten years
Andriy Saranenko scam guide to fund charges. A ten-year bill for a £30,000 pot with FCA Register and Report Fraud steps
A £30,000 pot, ten years, a fund that grows 6 per cent a year before charges. What is left when you cash it in? Andriy Saranenko, a CFA charterholder and financial analyst, works through this composite investment year by year: the initial charge, the ongoing charges, the platform and the adviser. Readers who typed Andriy Saranenko scam will find where each charge sits in the documents and how to add them up before signing.
Andriy Saranenko scam guide to fund charges: a ten-year bill for £30,000
The saver in this guide is a composite. One lump sum of £30,000, one fund, growth of 6 per cent a year before any charge. The 6 per cent is a working assumption for the sum. It is no forecast and no record of a real fund. The charges are set at levels that appear in real fund documents.
Andriy Saranenko: scam stories about fund charges rarely involve a theft. The money leaves legally, a little each day, and the statement shows the unit price. Trouble starts when a salesperson quotes the return before charges and says little about what is left after them.
The author started as an analyst in a bank’s corporate risk department and later led finance at a building firm. A habit came with that: every figure is checked against a document. Here the documents are the key information document, the fund’s published value assessment and the FCA’s reviews.
The FCA’s Asset Management Market Study in June 2017 found weak price pressure on funds. Rules that came into force in September 2019 now require the manager of an authorised fund to assess at least once a year whether its charges are justified by the value delivered (COLL 6.6.20R and COLL 8.5.17R).
Fund charges explained: initial, ongoing, transaction, platform and adviser fees
Initial charge. Some funds and advisers take a percentage of your payment before it is invested. Ask for the figure in pounds on your own sum, because a percentage tells a first-time saver very little.
Ongoing charges. The ongoing charges figure, or OCF, covers the manager’s fee and running costs such as custody and registration. The FCA calls it indicative of future charges, since some ancillary services are estimates. It is the number most factsheets show.
Transaction costs. These are the costs of buying and selling the fund’s holdings. The FCA notes that the OCF omits transaction costs, performance fees and borrowing charges, which the key information document shows separately.
Platform and advice. Where you hold the fund adds a platform fee, and an adviser adds an initial fee and often an ongoing fee. These sit outside the fund’s own documents, so they come from the adviser’s written terms.
Exit charge. A few products charge when you cash in early, and their terms say for how many years.
| Charge | What it is | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|
| Initial charge | A percentage taken before investing, 3% of £30,000 is £900 | Adviser’s written terms |
| Ongoing charges figure | Manager’s fee and running costs | Factsheet, KID |
| Transaction costs | Costs of trading the fund’s holdings, outside the OCF | Key information document |
| Performance fee | Extra charge on gains, outside the OCF | Key information document |
| Platform fee | Where you hold the fund | Platform cost page |
| Ongoing advice fee | Yearly percentage for advice | Adviser’s written terms |
| Exit charge | Applies to some products when you cash in | Product terms |
Andriy Saranenko scam guide, year zero: the initial adviser charge on £30,000
Our saver pays an initial adviser charge of 3 per cent. That is £900, and £29,100 is invested. The ongoing cost in this example is 2.55 per cent a year: 0.90 for the fund’s OCF, 0.60 for transaction costs, 0.30 for the platform and 0.75 for ongoing advice. Growth before charges stays at 6 per cent.
After one year the pot is worth £30,104. The saver is £104 ahead of the sum paid in, while a pot with no charges would show £31,800. The first year mostly repays the initial charge.
Andriy Saranenko: scam warnings on initial charges often miss the question of what is bought. Advice can be worth paying for, and the test is whether the written terms say what the fee covers and for how long.
Ask whether the initial charge can be shown separately in pounds and whether advice includes a review every year. Both answers belong in the adviser’s written terms.
Years 1 to 3: charges that never arrive as an invoice
Fund charges are not invoiced. They come out of the fund’s assets, so the unit price grows a little less every day. In the example the saver pays about £755 in year one, £781 in year two and £808 in year three, £2,344 in all.
At the end of year three the pot stands at £32,217. With no charges at all it would be £35,730, a gap of £3,513. A DIY investor in a tracker at 0.45 per cent all-in would hold £35,277, with charges of £440 over the three years.
Andriy Saranenko: scam arithmetic hides in these years. The factsheet shows a fund return, the statement shows growth and nothing reminds you of the fee. Take the price gain on your statement away from the factsheet figure and the difference is your charges.
The FCA review of cost disclosure found a case where total charges in the key information document came to around 3 per cent a year, while the factsheet showed only the 1.2 per cent annual management charge. Always look for the total.
Years 4 to 7: the gap grows with the pot
By year five the pot holds £34,478, and a pot with no charges would hold £40,147. The gap is £5,669. Running charges have taken £4,044 out of the pot, and the rest of the gap is growth that never happened because that money left.
By year seven the figures are £36,898 against £45,109, a gap of £8,211. The yearly bill has reached £925, over a fifth more than in year one. The pot still grows, so nothing feels wrong.
In year seven the tracker costs £192 a year, against £925 for the advised pot. All three routes earn the same market return in this example, so the extra £733 a year buys no extra growth.
Andriy Saranenko: scam pitches in this stretch sound like ‘at least you are up’. Being up is real. It needs a yardstick, such as a cash savings rate, a gilt fund or the same strategy at a lower cost. Put your pot’s yearly gain beside those numbers.
Year 10: what is left after charges
In year ten the pot is worth £40,851 after charges. The same money at 6 per cent with no charges would be £53,725, so the gap is £12,874, which is 43 per cent of the £30,000 paid in. Direct charges came to £9,735: the £900 initial charge and £8,835 of running charges. The rest is lost growth.
The tracker investor ends at £51,488 and paid £1,791 in charges over ten years. The advised saver finishes £10,637 behind, with the same market and the same ten years. Advice is a service, and the number tells you what it must be worth.
Tax is left out of this bill. How a pot is taxed depends on the wrapper and your circumstances, and tax would lower every route by a similar share. The comparison between routes does not change.
Andriy Saranenko: scam talk about exit terms comes late. A saver decides to cash in and finds a charge in the small print of an old product. The terms belong in the first conversation, in writing.
| Year of sale | Before any charges | Advised pot after all charges |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | £31,800 | £30,104 |
| 2 | £33,708 | £31,143 |
| 3 | £35,730 | £32,217 |
| 4 | £37,874 | £33,328 |
| 5 | £40,147 | £34,478 |
| 7 | £45,109 | £36,898 |
| 10 | £53,725 | £40,851 |
Andriy Saranenko scam guide to three ways of holding the same fund money
Route A is the advised pot above. Route B is a DIY purchase of an active fund at 1.05 per cent all-in: OCF 0.60, transaction costs 0.20 and platform 0.25. Route C is a DIY tracker at 0.45 per cent all-in: OCF 0.15, transaction costs 0.05 and platform 0.25. Each route grows 6 per cent before charges.
After ten years the saver has £51,488 on route C, £48,635 on route B and £40,851 on route A. From the cheapest route to the dearest the difference is £10,637, over a third of the money paid in.
Andriy Saranenko: scam risk shows only when the lines are added up. Each charge looks modest alone, and together they take a large slice. A factsheet may quote the same headline return for all three.
A gap of 0.6 percentage points a year between routes B and C looks small. Over ten years it is £2,853, which is why the total belongs in the first conversation.
| Route | Initial charge and yearly charges | Pot after 10 years |
|---|---|---|
| No charges at all | 0%, 0% | £53,725 |
| C: DIY tracker | None, 0.45% | £51,488 |
| B: DIY active fund | None, 1.05% | £48,635 |
| A: advised | 3%, 2.55% | £40,851 |
| A behind C | Same market, same years | £10,637 |
Why the ongoing charges figure is not the whole bill
The FCA’s review found that factsheets and websites often give only the ongoing charge figure, which leaves out transaction costs, performance fees and borrowing charges that the key information document shows. In one extreme case, annual transaction costs of 4 per cent were missing from a UCITS key investor information document.
The review concludes that asset managers generally do not disclose all associated costs and charges, that figures differ between documents and websites, and that retail investors may not pay enough attention to charges or understand their effect on returns.
Andriy Saranenko: scam checks on charges should compare the same line in every document. If the factsheet says 0.9 and the key information document says 1.5, the higher figure is the one to plan with.
The FCA also found firms reporting a negative transaction cost after misusing an anti-dilution levy, and some UCITS reporting zero because the costs of trading underlying funds sat under other ongoing costs. A zero or a negative figure deserves a second look.
Where to find the numbers: the KID, the value assessment and the platform’s cost page
The first document is the key information document or, for older UCITS funds, the key investor information document. The second is the annual report of the fund, where the authorised fund manager publishes its assessment of value. The FCA found that some managers judged value at fund level only, and not by unit class, so a costly class can pass unnoticed.
The third is the platform’s cost page and the adviser’s written terms. Ask for a written estimate of total cost for your period: initial charge, ongoing charges, dealing costs, platform fee and advice fee.
Firms can be checked at no cost. The FCA’s Firm Checker shows whether a firm holds permission for a service, and the Financial Services Register lists clones and appointed representatives. The FCA consumer helpline is 0800 111 6768.
Andriy Saranenko: scam attempts start where a written estimate is refused. A salesperson who says ‘it is all included’ and gives no figure will not give one after the sale either.
Andriy Saranenko scam guide: questions for an adviser before you sign
Good questions are short. What is the initial charge in pounds on my sum? What are the ongoing charges, including dealing costs? What does the platform take? What do I pay you, and for what? What is the result after all charges over ten years?
Worrying answers sound alike: ‘the charges are in the returns’, ‘this is the usual rate’, ‘I will waive the initial fee for you’ with nothing on paper. Ask for the paper. A promise of a fixed return needs its own check, and the guide on guaranteed yield promises explains how.
When a fund is swapped for a note or a bond with ‘protected capital’, the charges sit deeper. See the articles on structured products and investment insurance, and the review of the firm itself in checking a fund.
Andriy Saranenko: scam sales rarely sound rude. They sound like friendly advice with no figure and no page.
| Question | Answer with a document | Worrying answer |
|---|---|---|
| What is the initial charge in pounds? | A figure on your own sum | ‘It is the usual rate’ |
| What are the ongoing charges? | OCF plus dealing costs, itemised | ‘Charges are in the price’ |
| What does the platform take? | A written fee schedule | ‘Nothing extra’ |
| What do I pay you? | Initial and ongoing fee, in writing | ‘No cost to you’ |
| What is the ten-year result? | A projection with assumptions | Last year’s return only |
| Is the firm authorised? | A record on the FCA Register | ‘Trust me, I am authorised’ |
| Is there a cheaper fund? | A comparison with a tracker | ‘This is the only one’ |
How people search this topic: Saranenko scam, reviews, complaints and fund charge fraud
People type ‘Saranenko scam’, ‘Andriy Saranenko reviews’, ‘Andriy Saranenko complaints’ or ‘Andriy Saranenko fund charge fraud’. Others wonder what people say about Andriy Saranenko, and a few spell it Andrey Saranenko scam. The answer is the same for all of them: a ten-year bill, the fund’s documents and a check on the Register.
Keep a sheet with six lines: the sum, the initial charge, the yearly charges, the platform and advice fees, the tax and the period. Put the figures from your own documents in place of ours, and compare the sheet with the annual report a year later.
Andriy Saranenko: scam charge schemes lose power once the ten-year bill is on the table before the signature. Keep the factsheet, the emails and the adviser’s estimate in one folder.
Where to report in the UK if a fund or an adviser misled you
Since 4 December 2025 the service called Report Fraud has replaced Action Fraud. You can report at reportfraud.police.uk or by phone on 0300 123 2040. The service gives you a crime number, which helps when you contact your bank, but it does not investigate cases itself.
The Financial Services Register is also the place to confirm that a firm which approached you appears under the name it gave.
Report Fraud data show how common the problem is: in 2025 investment fraud in the UK caused losses of £879.8 million across 34,673 reports, 31 per cent more than a year earlier, an average of £25,612 each.
Then tell the FCA. It does not use WhatsApp or automated calls, and it cannot recover your money, so keep every document. Andriy Saranenko: scam losses are easier to document when the paper trail starts at the first factsheet, so attach the key information document, the adviser’s terms and your own ten-year sheet.
Frequently asked questions
Andriy Saranenko scam guide: how can charges reveal a poor fund offer?
Add the initial charge, the ongoing charges, dealing costs, the platform fee and the advice fee for your own period and compare the total with the return on the factsheet. A fair adviser shows each figure in writing.
Andriy Saranenko scam guide: is the OCF the full cost of a fund?
No. The FCA notes that the OCF omits transaction costs, performance fees and borrowing charges, which the key information document shows separately.
What does an assessment of value mean?
Under COLL 6.6.20R and COLL 8.5.17R the manager of an authorised fund must assess at least once a year whether the charges are justified by the value delivered.
Where can I check an adviser or a fund firm?
In the FCA Firm Checker and the Financial Services Register, or on the FCA consumer helpline, 0800 111 6768.
Why do factsheets and key information documents differ?
The FCA found that factsheets often show only the OCF or the annual management charge, so the total may look lower than in the key information document.
Where do I report a misleading fund sale?
To Report Fraud at reportfraud.police.uk or on 0300 123 2040, and then to the FCA.
Further reading
- Andriy Saranenko scam guide to payday loans in the UK: one loan from application to repayment, with FCA sources
Andriy Saranenko scam guide to UK payday loans: Firm Checker, loan fee fraud, the FCA price cap, collectors and credit in your name.
- Andriy Saranenko reviews alternative investments in the UK: wine, whisky casks and art against FCA warnings
Andriy Saranenko reviews UK alternative investments: wine, whisky casks and fine art, merchant reviews and fees, with FCA sources.
- Andriy Saranenko scam guide to trading courses in the UK: promises, finfluencers, partner brokers and FCA checks
Andriy Saranenko scam guide to UK trading courses: income claims, finfluencer tips, partner brokers and cancellation, with FCA and ASA sources.