Skip to content
Andriy SaranenkoInvestor and financial analyst, CFA charterholder

Structured notes with capital protection

Andriy Saranenko fraud guide for UK savers: structured deposits, structured investments and capital protection

Written by Andriy SaranenkoPublished on 13 min read

Andriy Saranenko fraud guidance for UK savers starts with two products that are easy to confuse: the structured deposit and the structured investment. Both promise a return linked to an index, both are sold with talk of protecting capital, and only one of them is legally a deposit. Andriy Saranenko, an investor and financial analyst who holds the CFA charter, sets out how each works under FCA rules, how the Financial Ombudsman Service looks at complaints about them, where FSCS protection begins and ends, and how a fraudster borrows the whole vocabulary. It is meant for savers who have been offered such a product by a bank, an adviser or a cold caller and want to check it before committing money.

Andriy Saranenko fraud guide: structured products and deposits, UK checks

Andriy Saranenko fraud guide: structured deposit or structured investment

The FCA Handbook defines a structured deposit as a deposit that is fully repayable at maturity, with interest or a premium paid, or put at risk, according to a formula. The formula can involve an index, a financial instrument, a commodity or an exchange rate.

A variable-rate account that simply tracks an interest rate index such as SONIA is not a structured deposit. In the FCA's view, capital certainty is a feature of any kind of deposit, which is why the definition insists on full repayment of principal.

A structured investment is a different animal. It may be a note, a plan or a bond-like product whose payout also follows a formula, but the capital can come back smaller than it went in. The documents usually say so in a risk warning near the front, and that warning deserves more attention than the illustration of the best case.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks begin with the name on the documents. If the paperwork says «plan», «note» or «investment» and the salesperson keeps saying «deposit», ask which one you are signing.

The FCA explains why the separate definition exists at all: a number of regulated activities apply to structured deposits that do not apply to other deposits. For a saver, that means the sale of a structured deposit comes with its own rules, and the firm should be able to say which ones.

Andriy Saranenko fraud guide: structured deposit and structured investment compared under UK rules
QuestionStructured depositStructured investment
Legal natureA deposit under the FCA definitionA security or investment product
Capital at maturityFully repayableMay be less than invested
ReturnInterest or premium set by a formulaPayout set by a formula
FSCS if the provider failsDeposit limit £120,000Investment limit £85,000 if regulated
Poor performanceCapital returned, interest may be nilNot covered by FSCS
ComplaintsFirm, then the ombudsmanFirm, then the ombudsman
Andriy Saranenko fraud guide: a structured deposit is a deposit repaid in full at maturity, while a structured investment can return less.

How capital protection is built into a structured product

Most structured products combine two pieces. One behaves like a deposit or a bond and is meant to return your capital. The other behaves like an option and pays the extra return if the index or basket does what the terms require. Andriy Saranenko fraud guidance looks at each piece separately, because a fraudster usually describes only the first one.

Three numbers decide the outcome: how much capital is protected, how much of the index rise you share, and where any cap or barrier sits. A small change in any of them can turn an attractive brochure into a product that pays back capital and nothing else.

Some products also measure the index on several dates during the term. On those, a single bad day can trigger a barrier and change the payout for good. Ask for the list of observation dates, and check whether the product looks at closing levels or at any level reached during the day.

Andriy Saranenko suggests putting those three numbers and the measurement dates side by side before any meeting with an adviser ends. If they are not in the documents you were given, the documents are incomplete.

Andriy Saranenko fraud guidance adds a question about the formula itself: which published index level is used, on which dates, and who calculates the result. A product that cannot answer those three points clearly is asking for trust it has not earned.

Andriy Saranenko fraud warning: what the Financial Ombudsman Service looks at

The Financial Ombudsman Service says that capital protection at maturity does not, on its own, make advice suitable. The return is usually linked to indices or a basket of shares, so the risk is similar to investing in those assets directly, apart from the protected capital.

When it investigates, the ombudsman looks at whether the customer understood there was a risk of getting little or no return, whether the customer wanted capital protection at all, whether they could afford to lock their money away and whether the firm explained the risks. Pointing to the sales literature is usually not enough.

Sometimes, the ombudsman notes, the customer was never looking for protection, would have taken risk for growth, and ended up tied into a product for several years with little or nothing to show for it.

Andriy Saranenko fraud guidance draws one practical lesson from this: keep the fact find, the risk questionnaire and every document you were given. They are exactly what the ombudsman asks for. Its list of evidence also includes the attitude to risk questionnaire and the charges or fee structure document, so keep your own copies of both.

The ombudsman follows the FCA's dispute resolution rules, takes into account how the firm has tried to put things right, and considers whether the sale was made by a tied representative of a product provider or by an independent financial adviser.

Andriy Saranenko fraud check: what the Financial Ombudsman Service considers in structured product complaints
IssueWhat the ombudsman asksWhat to keep
Risk of little returnDid the customer understand itNotes of the meeting
Wish for protectionDid the customer want it at allFact find
Locking money awayCould the customer afford itYour budget at the time
Explaining riskMore than the sales literatureEvery document given
Tax40% or more for higher-rate payersYour tax band
ConcentrationToo much in one productShare of savings invested

Tax and concentration: Andriy Saranenko's two quiet checks

The ombudsman also looks at tax. When comparing a product with other options, it considers that a higher or additional-rate taxpayer would pay 40% or more of the return in tax, and whether the firm made that clear.

Concentration matters as well. The ombudsman says that even when a product was suitable, it can be unfair to lock so much of a customer's money into a single investment, and it then checks whether the firm explained how the product worked and what could go wrong.

Both checks are easy to run at home. Work out what the best-case return looks like after your own tax band, then ask what share of your savings would sit in one product with one provider for years. Andriy Saranenko fraud checks count that share first, because concentration is the one risk a buyer controls completely.

If either answer is uncomfortable, Andriy Saranenko's advice is to say so in writing to the adviser before signing. That note becomes useful evidence if the sale is ever questioned.

The tax question cuts both ways. If a product was sold to a non-taxpayer, the ombudsman considers whether the decision would have changed had they known the tax consequences, for example if the investment pushed them into the basic rate.

Andriy Saranenko fraud check: early exit and counterparty risk

Structured products are designed to return capital at maturity, and the ombudsman warns that a customer who surrenders early may not get all of it back. Money that might be needed during the term is better kept elsewhere. If the literature mentions surrender values, ask for them as figures for each year of the term.

Protection also depends on who owes it. A structured investment pays out only if the bank or counterparty behind it can pay. The protected figure in the brochure is a promise from that institution, and its name should be on the documents you sign.

The ombudsman checks the fact find to see whether it was clear the customer might need the money before the end of the term. That is a fair test for any buyer to apply before signing.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks treat a product with no named provider, or with a provider you cannot find anywhere, as a reason to stop. The same applies when the provider named in the brochure differs from the one named in the application form.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks on the counterparty are simple to run: find the institution's name in the documents, look it up, and ask yourself whether you would lend it the same sum for the same number of years with no index link at all.

Andriy Saranenko fraud guide: where FSCS protection begins and ends

For deposits, FSCS protects up to £120,000 per person, per bank, building society or credit union, if the provider is authorised by the PRA. Banks in one group sharing a licence count as one bank.

For investments the rules differ. If an authorised investment firm failed after 1 April 2019, FSCS can pay up to £85,000 per eligible person, per firm, provided the firm and the activity were regulated. It does not accept claims for poor investment performance.

Because a structured deposit is legally a deposit and a structured investment is not, the same index-linked brochure can sit under two different protection regimes. Ask the provider in writing which one applies, and confirm it with the FSCS protection checker. A verbal assurance from the salesperson is not a substitute for that written answer.

The confusion is familiar from life insurance bonds sold as savings; the differences are set out in the guide to life bonds sold as savings.

FSCS adds that it may help when a failed firm is short of the money or assets it was holding for clients, and suggests asking the firm to confirm that its service is regulated and FSCS protected. The FSCS Protected badge helps identify protected banks, building societies and credit unions.

Andriy Saranenko fraud check: the adviser or platform sells the product, the provider owes the money, and protection depends on authorisation.

Andriy Saranenko fraud guide to fake structured bonds

Fake products borrow the language of real ones. The FCA warns that share and bond fraud often comes from boiler rooms that cold call investors with worthless, overpriced or non-existent securities. The largest single loss recorded by police was £6 million.

Clones are common. The FCA Warning List includes clones of authorised firms that offered fixed bonds and savings, and the regulator advises contacting any firm only on details from the FCA Firm Checker.

Unauthorised firms may also ask you to tick a box saying you are a sophisticated, experienced or high-net-worth investor. The FCA notes that most people do not meet those criteria and that the tick can cost you access to the ombudsman and FSCS.

How to check a gilt, a bond issue and its seller is covered in the guide to fake bonds in the UK. Andriy Saranenko fraud checks stop the moment money is meant to go anywhere other than an authorised firm.

Clone firms use the name, the FRN and the address of real authorised firms, and copy their websites with small changes such as a different phone number. The FCA also warns that people who have already invested in a scam are often targeted again, sometimes with an offer to buy back the investment for a fee.

Checking the firm on the FCA Register

The FCA's advice is to deal only with authorised firms, to check that the firm has permission for the specific service in Firm Checker, to reply only on contact details from the Register and to look at the Warning List. With an unauthorised firm there is no access to the ombudsman or FSCS.

Permission matters as much as authorisation. A firm allowed to take deposits is not automatically allowed to advise on investments, and an appointed representative acting outside its principal's permissions may leave you without protection.

Suspected boiler room approaches can be reported to the FCA on 0800 111 6768. A call that came out of the blue, with pressure to decide that day, deserves that call. Note the number the caller used and the name they gave, and pass both on.

Andriy Saranenko's habit is to look up the firm before the second conversation, while nothing has been signed and no money has moved. A search takes a few minutes, and the Register shows the firm's own contact details to use from then on.

For high-risk investments in general, the FCA suggests keeping no more than 10% of net assets in them. Andriy Saranenko fraud guidance uses that as a ceiling for anything whose protection depends on a single counterparty and a formula.

Six checks Andriy Saranenko runs before signing

First, is the firm authorised and does it hold the right permission? Second, is the product a deposit or an investment, and what exactly do the documents call it? Third, how much capital is protected, and under what conditions?

Fourth, who is the bank or counterparty that owes the money? Fifth, what is the term, and what comes back if you leave early? Sixth, what does the best case look like after tax in your own band?

Then compare the product with something plain. A protected deposit at a PRA-authorised bank has a known rate and FSCS protection. A structured product has to beat that comfortably to justify its complexity. Ask the adviser to put the comparison in writing, with the deposit rate they used.

If the comparison needs a model you cannot run yourself, Andriy Saranenko's view is that walking away costs nothing.

Ask for every document before the meeting where you are expected to sign, and read them at home. The terms of an honest product do not change because the buyer took a day to think.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checklist: authorisation, product type, protection, counterparty, term and tax are checked before any money moves.

Andriy Saranenko fraud: complaints and reporting in the UK

If a genuine product was mis-sold, complain to the firm first. The ombudsman says you have six years from the event or three years from when you realised there was a problem, firms have eight weeks for most complaints, and you then have six months to go to the ombudsman. The service is free.

If you suspect fraud, contact your bank straight away and report it to Report Fraud, which replaced Action Fraud on 4 December 2025. The website is reportfraud.police.uk and the number 0300 123 2040 has not changed.

Offers of a guaranteed high return on bonds or savings follow a related script, described in the guide to guaranteed-return offers.

Andriy Saranenko fraud complaints are stronger with a timeline: who called, what was promised, which boxes you were asked to tick and when each payment left your account. Copies of the key features document and any illustration you were shown belong in the same folder.

Fraud complaints move faster: the ombudsman says firms have 15 days to respond to a complaint about fraud. Keep a copy of everything you send and note the date, because the time limits run from those dates.

Andriy Saranenko fraud guide: where to check and report in the UK
TaskWhereDetail
Check the firmFCA Firm Checker and RegisterPermission for the service
Check for clonesFCA Warning ListContact only via the Register
Report a boiler roomFCA0800 111 6768
Report fraudReport Fraud0300 123 2040
Complain about a saleFirm, then the ombudsmanSix months after the final response

Frequently asked questions

Andriy Saranenko fraud guide: is a structured deposit the same as a structured investment?

No. Under the FCA definition a structured deposit is a deposit repaid in full at maturity, with interest set by a formula. A structured investment can return less capital than you put in.

Andriy Saranenko fraud check: how do I spot a fake structured bond?

Check the firm and its permission on the FCA Register, look at the Warning List for clones, contact the firm only on Register details and never tick a sophisticated investor box you do not meet.

Does capital protection make a structured product suitable?

Not by itself. The Financial Ombudsman Service says the return is linked to indices or shares, so the risk resembles investing in them directly apart from the protected capital.

What does FSCS cover for structured products?

Deposits up to £120,000 per person per authorised bank, and investment claims up to £85,000 per person per firm when a regulated firm fails. Poor investment performance is not covered.

Can I get my money back early?

The ombudsman warns that surrendering before maturity may return less than your capital, even though these products are designed to repay capital at maturity.

Where does Andriy Saranenko suggest reporting structured product fraud in the UK?

Your bank first, then Report Fraud on 0300 123 2040 or reportfraud.police.uk, and the FCA on 0800 111 6768 for boiler room approaches.

Further reading

All articles