Skip to main content
Andriy SaranenkoInvestor and financial analyst, CFA charterholder

Trust management: the agreement clause by clause

Andriy Saranenko: trust management and managed accounts. The agreement clause by clause: manager, registration, strategy, fees, reports, exit

By Andriy SaranenkoPublished 12 min read

A managed account agreement usually arrives after a few friendly calls: someone introduces himself as a portfolio manager, offers to run your account for a share of the profit and asks you to sign today. In this Insights piece Andriy Saranenko, a financial analyst and CFA charterholder, reads such an agreement clause by clause: who the manager is, registration, strategy, fees, reporting and exit. Each clause is checked against SEC and Investor.gov guidance, the custody rules and the reporting channels of the SEC, the FBI and the FTC.

Andriy Saranenko: trust management and managed accounts, the agreement clause by clause with SEC and Investor.gov checks

Andriy Saranenko on trust management: what a US client is actually signing

Readers who search “Andriy Saranenko”, “Andrii Saranenko” or “Andrey Saranenko” may know the phrase trust management from Ukrainian or Russian-language finance, where it means handing money to a professional who trades for you. In US terms the closest arrangement is a discretionary account run by a registered investment adviser or a broker-dealer, and it rests on a written agreement.

All dollar amounts, rates and dates in the examples below are composite and exist only to show the arithmetic. Rules are cited only where they appear on SEC, Investor.gov, FINRA, SIPC, FTC or FBI pages.

The order is simple: six clauses of the agreement, then a comparison of a lawful managed account with a stranger who trades through your login, then questions for the manager and the steps to take if money is already gone. Andriy Saranenko suggests reading the clauses in this order because each one depends on the one before it.

Clause one: who the manager is and who signs for the firm

The first page names the parties. On the manager's side there should be a firm with a legal name, an address and a person signing in a stated capacity. Investor.gov explains that brokers generally must register with the SEC and join FINRA, while investment advisers register with the SEC or with a state securities regulator, and both can be looked up with free search tools.

That rule settles a common case at once. A personal account on a messaging app that offers to trade your money for a share of the profits is not a registered firm, however many screenshots of returns it posts. Investor.gov notes that most investment fraud in the United States is committed by unlicensed individuals and unregistered firms.

Andriy Saranenko also looks at who signs for the firm. A signature from a salesperson with no title and no reference to authority gives the firm room to deny the agreement later. A scanned page sent in a chat is not an original, so ask for paper or an electronic signature through the firm's own system.

Check the status too: IAPD shows whether a registration is current, and a firm that was registered years ago may no longer be. Some firms operate under several names, and a scheme may borrow one of them for its paperwork.

Andriy Saranenko: the adviser acts under the agreement, and the assets stay with a custodian in the client's name.

Andriy Saranenko: registration, IAPD and Form CRS

Clause two is registration. The SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure database, IAPD, covers advisers registered with the SEC and most state-registered advisers, and it shows the current Form ADV, the relationship summary called Form CRS and the registration status. Brokers can be checked in FINRA BrokerCheck, which lists registrations and employment history over ten years and disclosures about customer disputes and disciplinary events.

Contact details matter as much as the record. The SEC advises finding the firm through the search on Investor.gov, opening its Form CRS and reaching the firm only by the phone number or website listed there, never through contacts the person supplies or posts on social media.

The record has limits. On December 11, 2024 the SEC and the FBI warned of a significant rise in complaints about impostors who copy a real professional's registration number and history from BrokerCheck and IAPD and post invented client reviews. In this analysis Andriy Saranenko treats a matching name as the start of the check, and the Form CRS contacts decide it. The fund-level version of this check is in the guide on checking a fund and its manager.

Andriy Saranenko: six clauses of a managed account agreement and where to check each in the US
ClauseWhat the agreement should sayWhere to check
Who the manager isFirm name, address, signer's roleIAPD or FINRA BrokerCheck
RegistrationSEC or state registration statusForm ADV and Form CRS
StrategyInstruments, limits, risk you acceptWritten mandate attached to the agreement
FeesRate, base and how fees are collectedFee schedule and Form CRS
ReportsFrequency and contents of reportsCustodian statements sent to you
ExitNotice, transfer in kind, payout timingTermination section before signing

Clause three: strategy, restrictions and limits of authority

The strategy section says what the manager may buy, in what proportions and under which limits. Without it the agreement reads like a blank power over your money. A useful mandate names the allowed instruments, the largest position in a single issuer, the currency, the drawdown you accept and outright bans, such as borrowing against the portfolio.

Ask how the manager learned about your goals, time horizon and tolerance for loss. A firm that never asks those questions cannot tie its strategy to you, and a strategy written to fit everyone fits nobody in particular.

Promises of return deserve a separate read. Investor.gov lists high returns with little or no risk, overly consistent returns, unregistered investments, unlicensed sellers and secretive or complex strategies among the red flags of a Ponzi scheme. If the projected return is printed in larger type than the description of the strategy, Andriy Saranenko suggests putting the agreement aside. How to read such promises is covered in the article on guaranteed yield claims.

Andriy Saranenko: fees on a composite dollar example

Clause four is the price. The agreement should state each fee, the base it is charged on and how it is collected. Investor.gov suggests asking about the total cost to buy and sell, the ongoing fees, how much an investment must grow just to break even and how the professional is paid: by commission, as a percentage of assets or in some other way.

A composite example. A client places $100,000 in a managed account with an annual advisory fee of 1 percent of assets, charged on the opening value. Over the year the account grows to $106,000: the fee is $1,000 and the client keeps $105,000 before taxes. If the account falls to $95,000, the asset-based fee is still charged under these composite terms.

If the agreement adds a performance fee, ask whether it applies to any gain or only to gains above the account's previous high. The second version keeps a client from paying twice for the same recovery after a loss.

The trader who works through your login counts differently: half of the profit sent to his card or a crypto wallet, plus a connection deposit and an account insurance fee. Andriy Saranenko reduces this clause to one question: where is the signed document with the numbers.

Fees compound over long periods, and a ten-year calculation is in the guide on fund fees.

Clause five: reports, custody and where the money really sits

Under the SEC custody rule, an adviser, with limited exceptions, keeps client funds and securities with a qualified custodian, such as a bank or a registered broker-dealer, in a separate account in the client's name or in an account that holds only client assets, and may not list itself as the principal on the client's account.

Statements are the test. According to the SEC bulletin, the custodian itself sends account statements at least quarterly, and an adviser with access to client assets undergoes an annual surprise examination by an independent accountant. If no statement arrives directly from the custodian, Investor.gov advises finding out why.

A chart in a web dashboard is not a statement. If the adviser's report and the custodian's statement disagree and the issue is not resolved, Investor.gov suggests contacting the SEC, or the state securities regulator through nasaa.org if the adviser is state-registered. Andriy Saranenko recommends agreeing on the contents of the report in advance: opening and closing value, trades with dates, fees deducted and cash movements.

A good report reconciles: the opening value plus deposits, minus withdrawals and fees, plus or minus market movement equals the closing value. When the arithmetic fails, ask for the trade list behind it and compare it line by line with the custodian's statement.

Andriy Saranenko: every clause of the agreement can be tested against a record you open yourself.

Andriy Saranenko: a managed account versus a stranger with your login

The trader-on-trust scheme looks like this: you open an account on a platform yourself, then hand the login and password to a specialist or install remote access software so that he can trade for you. There is no advisory agreement, no registration and no clear responsibility, while on paper the account is still yours.

The SEC alert of December 11, 2024 advises caution when someone wants to move the conversation to Telegram or WhatsApp, and it describes a case where investors were asked for account logins supposedly to connect to a copy-trading program and were then charged fees on withdrawals. A request for your credentials ends the check.

A lawful managed account works the other way round: assets sit with a qualified custodian in your name, the manager's authority is written into the agreement, statements come from the custodian and the registration is visible in IAPD or BrokerCheck. The table below compares the two models on seven points, and for a reader who searched “Andriy Saranenko” one mismatch is enough to stop a transfer.

Watch the platform as well. The specialist insists on one specific website or app and cannot say which firm operates it. Check that platform the way you check the manager: firm name, registration, contact details from Form CRS. If nobody can name the operator, there is no reason to open an account there.

Andriy Saranenko: a registered managed account versus a trader with your login, compared for US readers
PointRegistered managed accountTrader with your login
DocumentSigned advisory agreementChats and voice notes
RegistrationRecord in IAPD or BrokerCheckA borrowed name or none
AccessAuthority set out in the agreementYour login, password or remote access
Where assets sitQualified custodian, account in your namePersonal card or crypto wallet
StatementsSent by the custodian at least quarterlyDashboard screenshots
FeesWritten schedule, deducted per agreementHalf the profit sent by payment app
WithdrawalsPer termination termsRelease tax before payout

Clause six: exit, withdrawals and what protection does not cover

The last clause describes how the relationship ends: the notice period, how positions are sold or transferred in kind, when cash is paid out and any termination fee. If the exit is not written down, the manager will define it, and at the worst moment for you.

This is where schemes give themselves away. Investor.gov warns that when you try to withdraw, a fraudster finds an excuse, asks for more money or mentions fees and taxes for the first time, and it advises never paying to get your investment back or to unlock funds. A composite case: the dashboard shows $140,000, you ask for a withdrawal and are told to send a $14,000 release tax first.

SIPC protects customers of a failed SIPC-member brokerage firm up to $500,000, including up to $250,000 in cash, and it does not cover a decline in value, promised returns or unregistered investment contracts. Andriy Saranenko suggests asking before any transfer which firm holds the assets and under which agreement.

Read the notice period together with the trading terms. A long notice period plus a right to sell positions at the manager's discretion in the meantime can turn a planned exit into a forced sale at a poor price.

A composite exit. An agreement on $100,000 requires 30 days of written notice and carries no termination fee. The client sends the notice, the positions are transferred in kind to a brokerage account in his own name, and he decides later what to sell.

Andriy Saranenko: a registered manager holds written authority, while the trader on trust holds your password.

Andriy Saranenko: questions for the manager before you sign

Pressure is part of the pitch. FINRA lists unsolicited offers, urgency, exclusive access, claimed ties to well-known firms, a fund manager who cannot be found online, requests to send money to a person's own account and look-alike websites of brokerage firms among its red flags. The SEC and the FBI add that impostors pay people for fake video testimonials.

Seven questions in the table below separate a registered firm from an intermediary: a registered firm answers each in a minute and backs the answer with a document. Write the answers down. Andriy Saranenko suggests asking them even of firms that look reputable at first glance.

Searches such as “Andriy Saranenko reviews” or “Saranenko Andriy” lead to the same table, and the method does not change with the spelling of the query. The answers are checked against documents, and none of them replaces the record in IAPD or BrokerCheck.

Andriy Saranenko: seven questions for a US manager before signing and the answers that should stop you
QuestionRegistered firm's answerAnswer that should stop you
Where is your registration?IAPD or BrokerCheck, under the firm's name“We are an international team”
Who holds my assets?A named qualified custodian“Send it to my wallet”
Who sends my statements?The custodian, at least quarterly“Check the dashboard”
How are you paid?Percentage of assets per the fee schedule“We split the profit”
Do you need my login?No, authority comes from the agreement“Just share the password”
How do I contact the firm?Phone and website from Form CRS“Message me on Telegram”
How do I leave?Written notice under the agreement“Pay the release tax first”

If money is already gone: steps in the United States

Stop further payments, including any release tax or account insurance. Remove remote access software and change passwords for the brokerage account, email and banking apps. Keep the agreement, chats, screenshots, payment receipts and the website address, since such pages tend to disappear.

Report investment fraud to the SEC at sec.gov/tcr or by phone at 1-800-732-0330, to the FBI at ic3.gov, to the CFTC through cftc.gov/complaint and to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. The SEC Office of Investor Education and Assistance also takes questions at Help@sec.gov and advises anyone who suspects fraud to stop communicating and send no more money.

Be just as strict with any offer to recover your money for an upfront fee. Investor.gov lists people who have already lost money among the targets of advance fee fraud, with the payment described as a fee, a tax, a commission or an expense that will supposedly be refunded later. The steps are the same whether the query was “Andriy Saranenko CFA”, “Andrii Saranenko investor” or the surname “Saranenko” alone.

Write a timeline while the details are fresh: dates of calls, names and numbers used, amounts and the accounts or wallets that received the money. The SEC, the FBI and your bank will ask for exactly this, and a written record saves repeated explanations.

Questions and answers

Andriy Saranenko: how do I check that a portfolio manager is registered in the US?

Search IAPD for advisers and FINRA BrokerCheck for brokers, open the firm's Form CRS and contact the firm only through the phone number or website listed there.

Andriy Saranenko: should I give a trader my account login?

No. The SEC has described a case where investors were asked for logins supposedly for a copy-trading program and were later charged fees on withdrawals. A registered manager acts under a written agreement.

Where should the money in a managed account be held?

Under the SEC custody rule, with limited exceptions, with a qualified custodian such as a bank or a registered broker-dealer, in an account in your name or one that holds only client assets.

Who sends the account statements?

The custodian sends statements directly at least quarterly. If they do not arrive, Investor.gov advises finding out why.

Does SIPC cover losses in a managed account?

SIPC protects customers of a failed member brokerage firm up to $500,000, including $250,000 in cash, and does not cover a decline in value or promised returns.

Where do I report a fake portfolio manager?

To the SEC at sec.gov/tcr or 1-800-732-0330, to the FBI at ic3.gov and to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

More insights

All insights