Skip to content
Andriy SaranenkoInvestor and financial analyst, CFA charterholder

Crowdinvesting and collective investment platforms

Andriy Saranenko fraud guide: one crowdinvesting project read stage by stage, with Firm Checker, Register and Report Fraud steps

Written by Andriy SaranenkoPublished on 12 min read

A project page loads on a phone: a regional bakery is raising money for a second oven line, the minimum stake is small, the projected return looks friendly and the round closes in three days. Andriy Saranenko, a CFA charterholder and financial analyst, reads such a project from selection to failure and names the question at each stage that a register or a document can answer. Anyone who searched Andriy Saranenko fraud will find a way to tell an authorised platform from a lookalike, and a lookalike from an ordinary business failure.

Andriy Saranenko fraud guide cover for an analysis of a crowdinvesting project read stage by stage in the UK
Andriy Saranenko fraud guide: a crowdinvesting project read stage by stage, with FCA checks

Andriy Saranenko fraud warnings begin with the life of one crowdinvesting project

The project here is a composite: a regional bakery raising small stakes from many people through one platform. It carries no name, since the order of events is what counts: selection, funding, closing the round, reporting, exit and failure. Any project on any platform passes the same six stages, and each has its own question.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud around crowdinvesting seldom forges all six stages together. The swap normally hides in a single link, such as a platform that no one authorised, money sent to a ‘coordinator’s’ account or a report that is only a screenshot. Each stage below gets one check that a primary source can settle.

The author entered finance at a bank, working on corporate risk, and later served as finance director of a construction firm. One habit stays with every line: the terms and the register come first, the forecast in a polished page second.

One line belongs at the top. The FCA says that loan-based and investment-based crowdfunding are high risk, that there is no access to the Financial Services Compensation Scheme, and that a person could lose everything invested.

Method matters here. The analyst fixes one rule before opening any page: no payment until the agreement, the Firm Checker result and the fee statement have each been read once and saved. That takes an evening and takes the sting out of a countdown.

What the investor is buying and what the FCA regulates

The FCA divides crowdfunding into kinds. Loan-based, or peer-to-peer, crowdfunding connects borrowers and lenders who receive repayments, usually with interest. Investment-based crowdfunding means buying shares or business-backed loans in small and medium-sized companies. Both are on the regulated list.

Donation-based crowdfunding and rewards-based or pre-payment crowdfunding sit outside that list. A contributor to a rewards project receives a product or benefit and is not called an investor, and if such a project fails the contributor is unlikely to be protected.

For the bakery this yields a first question: which of these four am I paying into. Fraud that borrows the word crowdfunding likes to blur the answer and says ‘you will be a co-owner’ where the paperwork shows a reward or a loan. Andriy Saranenko: fraud around crowdinvesting counts on nobody opening the agreement before the payment.

Ask the platform in writing which of the four kinds this is and what the agreement gives you: a repayment date, interest, or a stake in the company. If the page and the agreement disagree, the gap goes back to the platform as a written question.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks: six stages of a crowdinvesting project and the investor’s question at each
StageInvestor’s questionWhere to find the answer
1. SelectionDoes the firm hold permission, who is the borrowerFirm Checker, Financial Services Register
2. FundingAm I inside the 10 percent rule, did I see the riskPlatform questionnaire, FCA guidance
3. ClosingWhich fees and taxes apply to my stakeWritten reply from the platform
4. ReportingWhat is reported and how oftenAgreement, platform updates
5. ExitIs a sale to another investor offered at allPlatform terms, FCA guidance
6. FailureWhat to write and what to keepWritten request, Report Fraud, an adviser

Stage 1. Selection: a firm in Firm Checker and a business with a name

The first question is about the platform. The FCA Firm Checker shows whether a firm has permission for a specific service, and the FCA suggests checking every firm in the deal so that you see what each may do. On average the Checker updates within 24 hours.

Use its limits honestly. The FCA warns that Firm Checker does not confirm that FSCS or Financial Ombudsman Service protection will definitely apply, and does not show whether a firm may hold client money. That detail sits in the Financial Services Register. Andriy Saranenko: fraud around crowdinvesting hopes the reader has no spare minute for this.

The second question concerns the borrower or company. Who is it, who owns it, what does it do and where does the page say the money goes? For property development projects the FCA names extra risks: the company may fail to finish or to repay, foreign laws and currency changes can touch returns, and money can be pooled across several projects.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud around crowdinvesting forges this stage at the lowest cost. It builds a site, calls it ‘members only’ and asks you not to search registers because ‘authorisation is being finalised’. For an analyst there is one answer: no permission in Firm Checker, no talk about money.

Run the search in a fresh browser window and type the address yourself. Lookalike sites copy a logo within hours, and a link from a chat or an advert leads to the copy. Compare every letter of the address with the one on your own saved paperwork.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks for crowdinvesting, a comparison of a firm on the FCA Register and a members-only platform from a chat link across five signs
Andriy Saranenko fraud checks: a ‘members only’ platform loses to a firm on the FCA Register on the very first row.

Andriy Saranenko fraud at the funding stage: the 10 percent rule, pressure and risk

The round is open and a bar shows the sum raised. The first limit is the FCA’s. On 4 June 2019 the FCA confirmed rules for peer-to-peer platforms: retail clients who are new to P2P and have no regulated advice are capped at 10 percent of their investable assets, and a platform without advice must assess an investor’s knowledge and experience.

A made-up stake for scale: £1,000 against £20,000 of investable assets is 5 percent, inside that cap. Check the platform’s own questionnaire as carefully as the maths, because the assessment is part of the rule.

The second check is the projected return. In 2025 Report Fraud logged 34,673 reports of investment fraud with £879.8 million lost, 31 percent more reports than a year earlier and an average loss of £25,612. A page that promises a high return with no assumptions deserves a written question before any payment.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud around crowdinvesting also runs a countdown, with ‘two places left’ and ‘a bonus for the first ten’. A regulated platform gives time to read the terms and does not hide the deadline behind a countdown.

Decide the figure before opening the page, together with the sum you could lose completely. An investor who has settled that number in advance steps back more calmly when the pressure builds.

Andriy Saranenko fraud guide: the six stages of a crowdinvesting project

Stage 3. Closing the round: fees, taxes and where the money goes

The round is closing and a payment is due. The FCA advises people to understand what the money goes into, to be comfortable with the risk of losing everything and to check the fees and taxes that may apply. Ask for all three in writing before the payment, and keep the reply.

Tax can be a real question here. GOV.UK lists peer-to-peer loans and crowdfunding debentures among what the Innovative Finance ISA can hold, with up to £20,000 payable into ISAs in the 2026 to 2027 tax year, which runs from 6 April to 5 April. Whether a particular holding qualifies is a matter for the platform’s documents.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud asks for the stake to be sent to a personal account ‘to speed things up’. Payment details come from the platform’s own pages, and any request to send money somewhere else closes the question.

Keep a dated copy of the platform’s reply on fees and tax. If a charge later appears that the reply never mentioned, the dated message is the evidence, and the platform can be asked to explain the difference in writing.

Look at where the money sits between your payment and the business. A platform that explains this in plain words, with named parties, has done part of your homework. A page that says only ‘secure payment’ has left it for you.

Andriy Saranenko fraud and the kinds of crowdinvesting risk, what each looks like and what to check
Kind of riskWhat it looks likeWhat to check
Loss of the whole stakeThe business does not surviveRisk warning, project updates
No FSCS coverA failure leaves no compensation routeFCA crowdfunding guidance
Slow exitReturns come years later or neverSale terms in the agreement
Property riskProject not finished, money pooledAgreement, borrower’s accounts
Lookalike platformA ‘members only’ site off the RegisterFirm Checker, Warning List
Recovery roomAn upfront fee to get money backFCA, Report Fraud
Andriy Saranenko fraud in crowdinvesting breaks one of six stages, a diagram of a project on a platform in the UK: selection, funding, closing, reporting, exit, failure
Andriy Saranenko fraud checks: an honest project has a document at each of the six stages, a fake skips at least one.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud instead of reporting, stage 4 and how to read an update

The round closed and the business trades. For the coming months the investor lives on updates. What the company must report and how often is written in the agreement, so the first question is what, how often and in what form. A line reading ‘updates on request’ means there are no regular updates. Andriy Saranenko: fraud around crowdinvesting steps past that line with talk of ‘everything in the portal’.

The author reads an update the way an analyst does: revenue and margin, cash in hand, debt, and the use of the raised money against the plan on the page. If the money went elsewhere, a written question follows. If revenue grows while cash shrinks, the cause usually sits in stock, purchases or loans to connected parties.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud sends a screenshot of a ‘dashboard’ with a green line. A real update arrives as a document with dates, sums and signatures. A chart with no source papers confirms nothing.

A habit worth keeping: once a quarter, send the platform three written questions. What changed in revenue and debt? How much of the money is left and what was it spent on? Did the owners or managers change? File the answers next to the agreement.

Set one update beside the last. Smooth growth with no seasonal dip, or round figures every quarter, is a reason to ask for the underlying accounts.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud and the exit, stage 5, with a sale that is not guaranteed

An exit means getting money back: a loan repaid, shares bought back, a sale to another investor or a sale of the business. The FCA says returns may arrive only after years and that the money may not come back quickly, or at all.

Some platforms let an investor sell to another investor after a delay. The FCA warns that this is not offered everywhere and that the seller may not get back the whole sum. Ask to see such a route in the written terms. A manager’s promise does not count as a term.

Fraud that copies a platform advertises ‘early withdrawal’ as a perk. It lets a small sum out to earn trust, then asks for a tax, a fee or ‘verification’ to release a larger one. An analyst also counts three scenarios in advance: money back in full, in part, or not at all, and sizes the first stake so the third does not break the household budget.

Put the horizon beside the stake: the delay before any sale to another investor, the repayment date in the agreement and the realistic end of the business plan. The longest of these is the one to plan around.

Andriy Saranenko fraud checks follow the money, a diagram of a pound from the investor through an authorised platform to the borrower or company with Firm Checker lookups
Andriy Saranenko fraud checks: a regulated platform sits between the investor and the business and can be found in Firm Checker.

Stage 6. When the project fails: no FSCS, a written request and recovery offers

Not every project in which investors lose money is a fraud. A business can fail to a competitor, a jump in costs or the loss of a key customer, and then the warning about loss does its work. Failure is told from fraud by documents: the money was spent on what was stated, the updates arrived and the platform answered. Andriy Saranenko: fraud around crowdinvesting is dangerous precisely because it passes for an ordinary failure.

The FCA states that for loan-based and investment-based crowdfunding there is no access to FSCS. When payments stop, write to the platform and the business, ask how the raised money was used, and save the agreement, payment confirmations and emails in one folder.

The FCA describes a recovery room as an approach to people who already lost money, offering to get it back for an upfront payment called a tax, a lawyer’s fee or an administration charge, sometimes in the name of the FCA, the government or the police. Andriy Saranenko: fraud returns this way after a loss, and the total losses can exceed the first.

If the business becomes insolvent, the position of an investor depends on the kind of holding and on the insolvency process. Show the agreement and the folder to an adviser before any filing.

Police work best with dated material. Screenshots with timestamps, bank statements, emails and the receiving account details turn a report from a story into a file.

Andriy Saranenko fraud in crowdinvesting and where to report in the UK, registers and channels
WhereWhat you getWhen to use it
FCA Firm CheckerPermission for a specific serviceBefore any payment
Financial Services RegisterClient money and individual detailsAfter Firm Checker
FCA Warning ListFirms flagged as unauthorisedBeside the Checker
Report Fraud, 0300 123 2040A police fraud reportIf money has gone
FCA helpline, 0800 111 6768A person to speak toIf the firm lists no contacts
Police Scotland, 101A report in ScotlandIf you live in Scotland

Andriy Saranenko: fraud with a lookalike platform and where to report it in the UK

Since 4 December 2025 reports in England, Wales and Northern Ireland go to Report Fraud, which replaced Action Fraud, at reportfraud.police.uk or on 0300 123 2040. The FCA says a person who lost money should report to Report Fraud first and then to the FCA, and people in Scotland should call Police Scotland on 101. The FCA cannot recover the money.

The FCA consumer helpline is 0800 111 6768, open on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday from 8am to 5pm and on Thursday from 8am to 9am and from 10am to 5pm. The FCA advises using only the contact details in Firm Checker, checking the Warning List and sharing no passwords.

Andriy Saranenko: fraud may ring back as a ‘regulator’ after a report. A call that comes through a messenger is already the answer: end it and use the number printed on the agency’s own website.

The review in one line: six stages, six checks, and each check has a register or a line in the agreement. Andriy Saranenko, an analyst of financial markets, advises starting with the register and signing last.

Before reporting, gather the site address, the payment details and the dates of contact in a single note. Ten minutes of preparation makes the report easier to use.

Frequently asked questions

Andriy Saranenko fraud: how do I check a crowdinvesting platform in the UK?

Search Firm Checker for the firm and the service it is permitted to offer, then read the Financial Services Register for client money, and reply only to the contacts listed there.

Andriy Saranenko fraud: is crowdinvesting covered by the FSCS?

No. The FCA says loan-based and investment-based crowdfunding are high risk and have no access to the Financial Services Compensation Scheme.

How much can a new retail investor put into peer-to-peer lending?

FCA rules confirmed on 4 June 2019 cap retail clients new to P2P, with no regulated advice, at 10 percent of investable assets.

Can I sell my stake whenever I like?

No. Some platforms let investors sell to another investor after a delay, but not all, and you may not get back the whole sum.

Can an investor lose everything in crowdfunding?

Yes. The FCA says returns are not guaranteed and that you could lose all the money invested.

Where do I report a lookalike crowdinvesting platform?

To Report Fraud at reportfraud.police.uk or on 0300 123 2040, and then to the FCA on 0800 111 6768.

Further reading

All articles