Broker apps and their fakes
Andriy Saranenko scam check: one broker app screenshot read screen by screen, with BrokerCheck, SEC and FINRA steps
A message arrives in a chat: one image, eight phone screens stitched into a strip, and a caption, ‘Install from the link, the bonus ends tonight.’ A store listing, an install button, sign-up, a profit chart, a ‘private terminal’, a deposit, a withdrawal. Andriy Saranenko, a CFA charterholder and financial analyst, reads such a screenshot screen by screen and notes on each one what a registered broker shows and what a fake shows. Readers who typed Andriy Saranenko scam will see how not to put a stranger’s program on their phone.
Andriy Saranenko scam checks start with one screenshot of eight screens
The screenshot in this guide is a composite. It is stitched together from screens that ‘managers’ send in chats: a store listing, an install button, a permissions prompt, sign-up, a portfolio, a terminal, a deposit and a withdrawal. The broker’s name is left off the image, because it changes every week while the order of screens stays the same.
Andriy Saranenko: scam apps rarely fake everything at once. The design usually looks like a real broker’s, and the swap hides in two or three places: where the program came from, where the money goes and what the balance shows. Each screen below therefore gets one question that a document or a register can answer.
The author started as an analyst in a bank’s corporate risk department and later served as chief financial officer of a construction company. One habit carries over to every line here: the registration record and the paper come first, the numbers in a polished interface second.
The scale is visible in the reports. IC3’s 2025 annual report counts 61,559 complaints about cryptocurrency investment fraud with $7.228 billion in losses, up 48 percent in complaints and 25 percent in losses on a year earlier. The FTC told Congress that consumers lost more than $7.9 billion to investment scams in 2025.
| Screen | What a fake shows | What to check at the source |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Store listing | ‘Pro’ in the name, identical reviews | Publisher matches the firm’s website |
| 2. Install link | File, profile or beta invitation | Store link from the firm’s own site |
| 3. Permissions | Messages, overlays, remote access | The app needs quotes and trade alerts only |
| 4. Sign-up | ID photos to a chat, a ‘license’ image | Firm and person on BrokerCheck |
| 5. Portfolio | A green chart with no fees | Custodian statement, trade confirmations |
| 6. ‘Private terminal’ | ‘Internal quotes’, orders inside the app | Registration, CUSIP, NFA BASIC |
| 7. Deposit | An individual’s account or a wallet | Custodian details from Form CRS |
| 8. Withdrawal | ‘Tax’, ‘fee’, ‘unlock’ payments | Fee schedule, no third-party payments |
Screen 1. The store listing: publisher, ratings and the ‘Pro’ in the name
The first screen is familiar to everyone: an icon, a name, stars and a download count. A fake relies on that trust. The SEC states that an app’s presence in a well-known app store does not mean the app, or any trading you see inside it, is legitimate.
FINRA adds that fraudulent apps may copy a firm’s branding with small changes to the name, such as ‘Pro’ or ‘Global’. Apple says that in 2025 the App Store rejected more than 2 million problematic submissions, removed almost 59,000 apps that switched functions after review to commit financial fraud and blocked about 195 million fraudulent ratings and reviews.
Andriy Saranenko: scam listings love a fresh page with dozens of near-identical five-star reviews. A genuine broker’s ratings vary, there are complaints and support replies, and the store link sits on the firm’s own website. Google reports blocking more than 1.75 million policy-violating apps from Google Play in 2025, so even a mainstream store works as a filter, not a guarantee.
The check takes a minute. Open the website of a broker you found on BrokerCheck, press the download button and compare the publisher name with what you see on the screen. If the website has no button and the app exists only in the chat, the question is answered.
Andriy Saranenko scam links: an install link instead of a store, screen 2
The second screen shows an ‘Install’ button and an address that leads around the store. On iPhone the common vehicle is TestFlight. Apple describes it as a tool for beta testing before public release: testers install a build from an email invitation or a public link, and a developer can have up to 10,000 external testers.
A registered broker with a public app has no reason to hand out a ‘private version’ in a chat. The FBI urges investors to be wary of unsolicited requests to download investment applications, especially from people they have not met in person.
Android has its own variant, a file you install by hand. Google says its protection blocked 266 million risky attempts to install apps from outside Google Play in 2025, and it is rolling out identity checks for developers: from September 30, 2026 in four countries, and on all certified devices from 2027.
Andriy Saranenko: scam messages add a countdown, ‘the link lives for an hour’. Urgency exists so that the person does not open BrokerCheck. A link from a conversation is fine for anything except the source of a program that will hold your money.
Screen 3. Permissions and remote access ‘to set things up’
The third screen asks for permissions: drawing over other windows, access to notifications and messages, sometimes control of the screen. A brokerage app needs the internet and trade alerts. The right to read messages with login codes has no connection to trading.
Then a ‘helper’ asks for access to the account or the device. In a case described by the SEC, investors were asked for their account logins supposedly to connect them to a copy-trading program. The FBI’s July 2025 warning about investment clubs names a request for access to a financial account as a red flag.
Andriy Saranenko: scam helpers see what you see, balances, codes, passwords. A real broker’s support does not need hands on your screen, and setup instructions live on its website. If access was already given, delete the program, change passwords from a different device and call your bank using the number on the back of the card.
The sequence matters here too. Permissions come first, the offer of a ‘helper’ second and sign-up third, so by the time ID photos are requested the device may already be open to a stranger. The eight screens below are laid out in the order in which the damage is done.
| Install source | What you see | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Store link on the firm’s website | Publisher matches the registered firm | Safe to install |
| App Store or Google Play search | Lookalike names, new pages, uniform reviews | A store is not proof |
| File sent in a messenger | Manual install outside any store | Do not install |
| TestFlight or profile link | A beta build by invitation | A broker needs no private build |
| Lookalike website | One character off the firm’s domain | Close it, use BrokerCheck |
| Link from a ‘group chat guru’ | Pressure and a countdown | Stop and verify |
Screen 4. Sign-up, the questionnaire and ‘verification’
The fourth screen looks harmless: name, phone, ID, a selfie with a document, ‘address confirmation’. A registered broker identifies a customer inside its own app and contract. A request to send ID photos to a ‘manager’ in a chat means the questionnaire serves another purpose.
Check the firm in parallel. Investor.gov says brokers must generally register with the SEC and join FINRA, and that the check is a free search. BrokerCheck shows ten years of registration and employment history, licenses and customer disputes. FINRA warns, however, that a fraudster may send a link to a real BrokerCheck profile or a doctored report, so search it yourself and compare.
Andriy Saranenko: scam sign-ups come with a ‘license’ image. In the SEC’s December 2025 case, three purported crypto asset trading platforms falsely claimed to hold government licenses. FINRA also notes that the SEC and other regulators do not issue certificates to firms or professionals.
A phone number should come from the firm’s Form CRS or public website, not from the pitch. Retirement money moved into a new account is covered in the guide on IRA and brokerage accounts month by month.
Andriy Saranenko scam profit: the growing portfolio on screen 5
The fifth screen shows what the whole scheme is for, a portfolio, a green line and ‘weekly return’. It looks like a statement and is not one. The FTC writes that the investment website a scammer steers you to looks real but is fake, and the FBI traced one app that used the name and logo of a real US financial institution.
Investor.gov describes the pattern as advance-fee fraud, often with invented account dashboards that show fast growth. In an FBI notice from July 2022 at least 28 victims lost about $3.7 million to such an app, and 13 of them were told by email to pay taxes before withdrawing.
Andriy Saranenko: scam dashboards change with one line of server code, while a custodian’s statement does not. Ask for trade confirmations and a statement from the custodian for the period, and compare each trade with market prices. The same trick with a slick presentation and a ‘backtest’ is taken apart in the guide on AI trading bots.
The cheapest proof in the whole scheme is a screenshot of someone else’s profit. An image takes a minute to draw, and FINRA notes that other members posting big returns in a group may be accomplices.
Screen 6. The ‘private terminal’: orders that never reach a market
The sixth screen shows a ‘professional terminal’ with a price ladder, open ‘to clients only’ and supposedly fed by ‘internal quotes’. In the SEC’s 2025 complaint the platforms did not execute any trades, and the token offerings they advertised came from businesses that did not exist.
A legitimate order has a price, a fee and a confirmation number that later appears in a statement. An order ‘filled inside the system’ leaves no trace outside it. FINRA advises confirming that the firm is registered and can sell the exact product offered, and for a security, looking up its CUSIP number.
For futures, forex and similar products the CFTC asks you to check registration first, and NFA BASIC is a free database for that. Andriy Saranenko: scam terminals avoid every register on that list, because each register would ask who stands behind the platform.
Screen 7. The deposit: whose account the app shows
On the seventh screen the app shows deposit details: an individual’s bank account, a ‘partner’ company or a crypto wallet. FINRA’s advice is to send money only to a registered firm or a regulated custodian. A request to pay with crypto, gift cards, cash or a payment app is named by the FTC as a direct sign of a scam.
Details on a screen can be swapped by whoever runs the server, so check them against paper. Call the broker on a number from Form CRS or its public website and ask for the bank and account name, then compare with the agreement. A mismatch stops the transfer.
Andriy Saranenko: scam apps send ‘updated details’ in a second message, often with a bonus ‘valid until tonight’. Where the money lands decides the rest. A custodian’s account shows up in a statement, an individual’s account does not.
Screen 8. The withdrawal: ‘tax’, ‘regulatory fee’ and ‘unlock’
The eighth screen appears when a person tries to cash out. The app says a ‘tax’, a ‘regulatory fee’ or an ‘anti-fraud check’ must be paid first. FINRA describes fake apps that offer a ‘trial period’, then block withdrawals and demand fees dressed up as taxes or regulatory requirements.
The FTC says that after logging in to such an account, you will not be able to withdraw your money at all, or only by paying high fees. In the SEC’s case the victims who tried to withdraw were asked for advance fees, and the money never came back.
Andriy Saranenko: scam cashiers end every withdrawal conversation with a new payment, while a legitimate broker shows fees and tax paperwork in its schedules and statements. Group chats where members cheer the profits belong to the same funnel, a pattern covered in the guide on fake brokers in chat apps.
A second wave follows. Investor.gov warns that people who already lost money get offers to recover it for a fee, a tax or a deposit. Paying to get your own money back is the same scheme with a new script.
Andriy Saranenko scam or genuine app: the verdict on eight screens
If the registration, the publisher and the install source do not match, the other screens can be skipped. The seven-step diagram beside the text is built to stay open on your phone while a ‘manager’ keeps sending screenshots.
Andriy Saranenko: scam apps fail screens 1, 2 and 4. A registered broker passes them in five minutes, because its filings, website and agreement have long been public.
The short video next to this section retells the guide: a store listing that proves nothing, up to 10,000 external testers in TestFlight, the BrokerCheck search, $14 million taken in the SEC case and the main advice to install nothing from a chat link.
Readers reach this page by different searches. Some type Andriy Saranenko fraud or Saranenko scam, others look for Andriy Saranenko reviews or Saranenko Andriy with the surname first, ask whether Andrii Saranenko is legit, or use the spelling Andrey Saranenko. The answer to every version is the same: question the screens and check the register.
| Where to check | What you see | When to use it |
|---|---|---|
| FINRA BrokerCheck | Registrations, ten-year history, disputes | Before any install |
| SEC Investor.gov and IAPD | Advisers and brokers, free search | When the person says adviser |
| SEC EDGAR | Filings of funds and offerings | When the app lists ‘securities’ |
| NFA BASIC | Futures and forex registrations | When the app trades forex or futures |
| SEC, IC3 and FTC report pages | Where to file a complaint | If money has gone |
Where to report a fake broker app in the US
The SEC accepts tips at sec.gov/tcr and answers at 1-800-732-0330. Report internet-enabled fraud to IC3, the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center, and file a report with the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. For futures and forex, the CFTC takes complaints at 866-366-2382.
FINRA runs the Securities Helpline for Seniors at 844-574-3577, open weekdays from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Eastern, and takes regulatory tips on its website. Contact a regulator before you share more personal information with a person who pressed you.
Keep screenshots of all eight screens, the chat history, the install link and every wallet address or account number you paid. Report the app to the store as well.
Andriy Saranenko: scam artists count on the checks looking slow. In practice BrokerCheck, EDGAR and the store listing fit into one evening, and the eight screens are worth saving for the next link.
Questions and answers
Andriy Saranenko scam check: can I install a broker app from a link sent in a chat?
No. A registered broker publishes its store link on its own website. A file, profile or beta invitation from a chat bypasses store review.
Andriy Saranenko scam warnings about remote access: what if a ‘helper’ asks for it?
Refuse. If access was already given, delete the program, change passwords from another device and call your bank.
How do I verify the publisher of a brokerage app?
Match the publisher with the firm named in your agreement and on its website, then search the firm and the person on BrokerCheck yourself.
Does an app in the App Store prove the broker is legitimate?
No. The SEC says availability in a well-known store does not make the app or its trading legitimate.
Why does the app ask for a tax before I can withdraw?
The FBI described victims told to pay taxes before withdrawing who still could not withdraw. Legitimate brokers show fees in schedules and statements.
Where do I report a fake broker app?
To the SEC at sec.gov/tcr, to IC3, and to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
More insights
- Andriy Saranenko scam checks on payday and small loans: one loan from application to payoff, with CFPB and FTC sources
Andriy Saranenko scam checks on payday and small loans: state licenses, advance fees, rollovers, debt collectors and loans in your name.
- Andriy Saranenko reviews alternative assets: wine, watches, art and coins by their ownership chain
Andriy Saranenko reviews alternative assets: wine, watches, art and coins, dealer reviews, buybacks and fees, with FTC, SEC and IRS sources.
- Andriy Saranenko scam checks for trading courses: promises, sellers, signals and partner brokers against SEC records
Andriy Saranenko scam checks for trading courses: income claims, signals, partner brokers and refunds, with SEC, CFTC and FTC sources.