Gold and bullion fraud
Andriy Saranenko fraud checks for gold buyers. Bullion markups, gold IRAs, stored metal and courier scams
Andriy Saranenko fraud guide for American buyers of gold: a CFA charterholder explains how legitimate bullion is priced, why coins carry far higher markups than bars, what the tax code allows in a precious metals IRA, how financed metal and stored metal schemes work, why couriers now collect gold from scam victims, and which federal agencies take reports when a deal goes wrong.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud risks in gold and who wrote this guide
Andriy Saranenko started as an analyst in a bank's corporate risk department, earned the Chartered Financial Analyst charter in 2016, later served as chief financial officer of a construction company, and since 2023 has worked in private asset management and venture investment. In the Insights section he reviews financial offers the way he would review a deal for his own portfolio.
Gold attracts sellers of bad deals for a plain reason: the metal has a reputation for lasting value, and that reputation can be borrowed. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission reminds buyers that gold, silver and platinum may be less safe than promoters suggest and face the same swings of supply and demand as other commodities.
According to Andriy Saranenko, fraud in this market tends to show up when prices are in the news and buyers are afraid of missing out. This guide starts with how the legitimate market prices metal, then walks through the schemes and the signs that expose them before any money moves.
No dealers are named or recommended here. The point is a method: the same questions an analyst asks of any deal, applied to a bar, a coin or a metals IRA, and checked against what federal agencies publish.
How the legitimate bullion market prices metal
Every physical purchase starts from the spot price. According to the CFTC, bullion usually sells at spot plus a markup, or premium, of 5 to 10 percent, while numismatic coins are often pitched at premiums from 40 to 200 percent above spot.
Spot prices are quoted per troy ounce, about 31.1 grams. The CFTC's own formula for the premium is simple: subtract the spot price from the sales price, divide by the spot price and multiply by 100. Two minutes with a calculator shows what a salesperson's «fair price» really means.
As explained by Andriy Saranenko, fraud often hides in the gap between what a dealer charges and what the same dealer will pay back. The CFTC's guide to gold IRA scams says this spread can run from 30 to 300 percent or more, and the wider it is, the further spot must climb before you break even.
The CFTC also suggests comparing premiums from several sellers. A profit appears only when the spot price rises enough to cover the premium plus the cost of selling the metal later, so the buyback quote matters as much as the purchase price.
Spot itself moves every trading day. A quote that looks cheap on Monday may simply reflect an older spot price, so compare offers within the same hour and ask each seller which spot figure they used.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud signs in a precious metals sales pitch
The CFTC lists the warning signs plainly. You are promised guaranteed returns. You are called out of the blue or get an offer by email. You hear that only precious metals hold value in a crisis, or that gold is about to reach its «highest values» in years.
More signs follow from the same brochure: the salesperson calls himself a «metals dealer» or «merchant» to sound legitimate, says metals deals are unregulated, offers a contract that does not say where the metal is or claims it will sit in an overseas vault, or promises big money with little risk through a financing agreement.
In the experience of Andriy Saranenko, fraud rarely arrives as an obviously fake bar. It arrives as urgency: a «once in a lifetime» opportunity, coins that will «only go up» because they are rare, a limited window before some predicted crash. The CFTC flags each of these lines.
The CFTC adds a detail worth remembering. Dishonest metals dealers buy ads around political and religious programming to borrow trust, use images of well-known people and fake their endorsements. The program airing the ad may know nothing about the advertiser.
A good test is to ask for everything in writing and then wait two days. Legitimate sellers send the documents and the offer still stands. A seller who calls back with a better «last chance» price has shown his method.
| Route | What to know | Main risk |
|---|---|---|
| Bullion bar or coin from a dealer | Spot plus a 5 to 10 percent premium | Spread between buy and buyback |
| Numismatic coin | Premiums of 40 to 200 percent | Common coin sold as rare |
| Precious metals IRA | Bullion must sit with a trustee | Fees that eat half the account |
| Financed purchase | Delivery required within 28 days | No metal ever bought |
| «Stored» metal with a dealer | A balance in an online account | Metal may not exist |
| Courier pickup after a call | Never legitimate | Total loss of the savings |
Gold IRAs: what the tax code actually allows
Under 26 U.S.C. 408(m), an IRA that buys a collectible is treated as making a distribution equal to the cost of that item. The IRS lists metals, gems, stamps and coins among collectibles, and says such a distribution is generally taxed as ordinary income, with a 10 percent additional tax possible before age 59 and a half.
There are narrow exceptions. Certain gold, silver and platinum coins issued under federal law qualify, and bullion of the required fineness qualifies only if a bank or an approved nonbank trustee keeps physical possession of it. The statute ties the bullion exception to that trustee.
As pointed out by Andriy Saranenko, fraud around gold IRAs often relies on buyers not reading this rule. A pitch that you can keep IRA bullion in your own safe ignores the trustee requirement, and a pitch for «rare» coins in an IRA ignores the CFTC's warning that only certain bullion coins can go in an IRA at all.
Fees are the other trap. The CFTC describes customers who lost half of their investment to fees, and one case where a dealer and custodian charged nearly $150,000 in commissions and fees on a $300,000 account rolled into a gold IRA. Its IRA guide adds that self-directed IRAs carry no special tax breaks, only more complex rules and higher fees.
| Cost | Typical size | Where it appears |
|---|---|---|
| Bullion premium | 5 to 10 percent above spot | Purchase |
| Numismatic premium | 40 to 200 percent above spot | Purchase of collectible coins |
| Dealer spread | 30 to 300 percent or more | Buy price against buyback price |
| IRA fees | Up to half the investment in reported cases | Rollover into a gold IRA |
| Storage and insurance | Monthly charges | IRA or dealer storage |
| Tax on a collectible in an IRA | Ordinary income, plus 10 percent before 59 and a half | Buying a collectible inside an IRA |
Andriy Saranenko: fraud with stored metal that never existed
The most expensive schemes need no bars at all. A firm offers to finance most of the purchase: the CFTC describes deals where the customer puts down 20 to 25 percent and the company lends the rest, then charges interest, margin, storage and insurance on metal held in its «vault».
Federal law draws a clear line here. Selling metal to retail customers on credit or margin breaks the Commodity Exchange Act unless the company is registered with the CFTC as an exchange or actually delivers the metal within 28 days. The CFTC says past investigations of such schemes found that no physical metal was ever bought for customers.
In the view of Andriy Saranenko, fraud of this type produces very convincing paperwork: monthly statements, storage certificates, an online balance in ounces. The CFTC has charged companies with selling gold that did not exist and then billing victims for storing it, insuring it and shipping it.
Three questions cut through the paperwork. Which depository holds the metal, in whose name, and when can you take delivery? A seller who cannot answer all three in writing is selling a promise.
Counterfeit coins and the «copy» rule
Only the U.S. Mint is authorized to manufacture United States coins. The Mint's guidance notes that counterfeiting laws fall under the Secret Service and the Department of Justice and cover coins that imitate U.S. or foreign money, including coins no longer in circulation.
Replicas are legal only with a label. The Hobby Protection Act requires imitation numismatic items to be plainly and permanently marked «copy», and under 15 U.S.C. 2101(b) making, importing or selling one without that mark is unlawful. The FTC administers the act.
In the words of Andriy Saranenko, fraud with coins usually looks like a bargain: a replica sold with the mark polished off, or a common bullion coin sold at a collector's premium. In both cases the buyer pays for something the coin is not.
The safest habit is to buy from a seller who issues a receipt with the coin type, weight and fineness and who quotes a written buyback price. A coin that arrives without either is worth what a skeptical dealer will pay for it, and no more.
If you already own a coin you doubt, ask an established dealer for an opinion before you insure it, sell it or pass it to family. Keep the original seller's details: they belong in any report you file later.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud by courier, the gold pickup scheme
On January 29, 2024, the FBI's IC3 described a scheme in which callers pose as tech support or government officials, claim the victim's accounts are hacked and tell them to turn savings into cash or precious metals. Sometimes victims are told to wire money to a metal dealer that ships the metal to their home.
A courier then collects the cash or metal at the victim's house or a public place, sometimes after checking a passcode such as the serial number of a dollar bill. Victims are told the assets will go into a protected account and never hear from the scammers again. IC3 counted over $55 million in losses from May to December 2023.
For Andriy Saranenko, fraud of this kind works because it borrows the authority of a bank or an agency. IC3's answer is short: the U.S. government and legitimate businesses will never ask you to buy gold or other precious metals.
IC3 also advises never sharing your home address with unknown callers or meeting strangers to hand over cash or metal. Report such contacts at ic3.gov. People aged 60 or older can get help filing through the DOJ Elder Justice Hotline at 1-833-372-8311.
Families can agree on a simple rule in advance: nobody withdraws savings, buys gold or meets a courier because a caller said so, without first phoning a relative on a number they already know.
Storage, insurance and the costs nobody mentions
Physical metal has to live somewhere. The CFTC notes that gold kept at home may not be covered by a homeowners policy, and gold stored with a bank or other facility usually comes with fees.
Precious metals IRAs and financed purchases add their own layer. The CFTC warns of monthly charges for administration, handling, storage and insurance, which keep running whether the price rises or falls.
In the analysis of Andriy Saranenko, fraud is easier to spot once these costs are written next to the promised gain. A pitch that mentions the future price of gold and never mentions the annual cost of holding it is missing the line that decides whether the deal makes money.
Ask for the full fee schedule before signing: setup, storage, insurance, account maintenance, shipping and the fee to sell. Any honest seller has that list ready. The same discipline applies to any product with a promised return, as the guide on guaranteed-yield scams shows.
Who must be registered, and how to check
The CFTC draws a useful line. Someone who tells you what to buy, how much, or when to buy or sell is giving investment advice and must be registered with the SEC (adviserinfo.sec.gov), FINRA (brokercheck.finra.org) or your state securities regulator.
Advice about futures or options may also require CFTC registration, which can be checked through the National Futures Association's BASIC database. The CFTC also points buyers to SmartCheck.gov to confirm that the company and the person selling are registered.
As noted by Andriy Saranenko, fraud survives on unchecked titles. «Senior metals strategist» or «retirement specialist» means nothing until a register confirms it. A step-by-step approach to checking a financial professional is laid out in the guide on checking a financier against official registers.
Before investing, the CFTC suggests learning how the product makes money and how it can lose money, checking claims with independent sources, and asking friends, family and trusted professionals for their view.
A registration check takes a few minutes and costs nothing. Skipping it to catch a «price that ends tonight» is the trade that most metals scams are built on.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud checks before you buy
A purchase takes five minutes of arithmetic. Write down the spot price, the seller's price, the seller's buyback price and the yearly cost of storage and insurance. The difference between purchase and buyback is your first loss, and the metal has to earn it back.
Then decide the size. The CFTC's guide to IRA scams says the safest strategy is holding a mix of assets, and gold prices can be as volatile as other commodities. Metal can protect part of your savings. It is a poor home for all of them.
By the reckoning of Andriy Saranenko, fraud depends on the buyer never doing this sum. The seller talks only about where gold might go and stays silent about premium, spread, fees and the time needed to cover them.
Products that link returns to gold through a note or a bond are a different and more complex category, and the guide on structured products with capital protection explains how to read their terms.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud reporting, where to go in the US
Precious metals fraud goes to the CFTC at cftc.gov/complaint. The agency's consumer line is 866-366-2382, and it asks buyers to verify a company's registration before sending any money.
Courier pickups and impersonation calls belong with the FBI at ic3.gov, as fast as possible. The FTC takes general fraud reports at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and suggests telling your state attorney general as well.
Per Andriy Saranenko, fraud reports work best when they are specific: dates, amounts in dollars, the dealer's name, website and phone numbers, and the account that received the wire. A precise timeline helps investigators link one case to others.
If a bank wire went out recently, call the bank at once and ask it to try to recall the payment. Keep every statement, invoice and recorded call, because a storage scheme often looks legitimate until someone asks to take delivery.
| Situation | Where to report | Contact |
|---|---|---|
| Overpriced or undelivered metal | CFTC | cftc.gov/complaint |
| Courier pickup or impersonation call | FBI IC3 | ic3.gov |
| General consumer fraud | FTC and state attorney general | ReportFraud.ftc.gov |
| Victim aged 60 or older | DOJ Elder Justice Hotline | 1-833-372-8311 |
| Wire sent in the last hours | Your bank | Ask for a recall |
A short checklist before buying gold
Check the seller's registration. Compare premiums with two or three other sellers. Get the buyback price in writing. Know where the metal will sit and in whose name. Add up every fee. Never hand cash or gold to a courier sent by a caller.
For an IRA, confirm the coins qualify and that a bank or approved trustee will hold the bullion. For coins sold as rare, assume bullion value until an independent dealer says otherwise.
If a deal already feels wrong, stop paying. Every further transfer, whether called a storage fee, a tax or a release charge, adds to the loss and rarely brings the metal any closer.
Andriy Saranenko boils it down to one rule: buy gold where you can sell it back, with a receipt for every ounce and no deadline pushing you.
Questions and answers
Andriy Saranenko fraud checks: is a gold dealer who cold-calls me legitimate?
The CFTC lists an unexpected call or email as a warning sign and advises against buying metal on the back of one. Check the seller on SmartCheck.gov before any payment.
Andriy Saranenko fraud warning: can I keep gold from my IRA at home?
Under 26 U.S.C. 408(m) bullion stays outside the collectibles rule only while a bank or approved trustee holds it. Otherwise the purchase can be treated as a taxable distribution.
How much markup is normal on gold bullion?
The CFTC puts the usual bullion premium at 5 to 10 percent over spot. Numismatic coins are often sold at 40 to 200 percent over spot.
Is it legal to sell gold on credit and store it for me?
Only if the company is registered with the CFTC as an exchange or actually delivers the metal within 28 days. Otherwise the sale breaks the Commodity Exchange Act.
Would a government agency ever ask me to buy gold?
No. IC3 states that the U.S. government and legitimate businesses will never ask you to purchase gold or other precious metals.
Where does Andriy Saranenko suggest reporting a precious metals scam?
To the CFTC at cftc.gov/complaint, to IC3 for courier or impersonation schemes, and to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
More insights
- Andriy Saranenko scam checks on payday and small loans: one loan from application to payoff, with CFPB and FTC sources
Andriy Saranenko scam checks on payday and small loans: state licenses, advance fees, rollovers, debt collectors and loans in your name.
- Andriy Saranenko reviews alternative assets: wine, watches, art and coins by their ownership chain
Andriy Saranenko reviews alternative assets: wine, watches, art and coins, dealer reviews, buybacks and fees, with FTC, SEC and IRS sources.
- Andriy Saranenko scam checks for trading courses: promises, sellers, signals and partner brokers against SEC records
Andriy Saranenko scam checks for trading courses: income claims, signals, partner brokers and refunds, with SEC, CFTC and FTC sources.