Crowdinvesting and collective investment platforms
Andriy Saranenko fraud check: one crowdinvesting project read stage by stage, with SEC, FINRA and Regulation Crowdfunding steps
A project card opens on a screen: a regional workshop is raising money for a second production line, the minimum check is small, the forecast reads well and the round ends in three days. Andriy Saranenko, a CFA charterholder and financial analyst, reads such a project from selection to failure and names the question at every stage that a document or a registry can answer. Readers who typed Andriy Saranenko fraud will find a way to tell a registered offering from a copy, and a copy from an ordinary business failure.
Andriy Saranenko fraud checks start with the life of one crowdinvesting project
The project in this guide is a composite: a regional workshop raising small checks from many investors through one online portal. It has no name because the order of events is what matters: selection, funding, closing the round, reporting, exit, failure. Every project on every portal passes the same six stages, and each stage has its own question.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud in crowdinvesting rarely fakes all six stages at once. The swap usually hides in one link: a ‘portal’ nobody registered, money sent to a ‘curator’s’ card, a report that is a screenshot. Each stage below therefore gets one check that a primary source can answer.
The author came to finance through a bank, where the work was corporate risk, and later ran the money of a construction company as its finance chief. One habit carries over to every line: the terms and the record come first, the forecast in a polished card second.
One fact belongs on the first line. FINRA writes that investments through crowdfunding carry significant risk and that an investor can lose part or all of the money. Everything that follows is read through that sentence.
A word on method. The analyst sets one rule before reading any card: no transfer until the offering terms, the registration lookup and the cancel window have each been seen once and saved. The rule costs one evening and removes the pressure of the countdown.
What the investor buys and from whom
Under the SEC’s Regulation Crowdfunding a company can raise no more than $5 million in 12 months, and every transaction goes online through an SEC-registered intermediary, either a broker-dealer or a funding portal. Securities bought in such a transaction generally cannot be resold for one year.
For the composite project this gives a plain first question: what is on the page you are about to sign. Shares, a note or another security are different claims on the same workshop. Fraud that borrows the word crowdfunding likes to blur the claim and says ‘you will be a co-owner’ without naming the security. Andriy Saranenko: fraud in crowdinvesting counts on nobody opening the terms before the transfer.
Read the offering terms before the card. The SEC page says an issuer discloses information in filings with the SEC and to investors and the intermediary, so the terms exist somewhere you can read them. A card that points nowhere is an answer in itself.
Ask in writing which security the company is selling and what rights it carries: a vote, a claim on assets, a repayment date. The answer should match the offering terms word for word. Any gap between the card and the terms goes back to the intermediary as a question.
| Stage | Investor’s question | Where to find the answer |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Selection | Is the intermediary registered, who is the issuer | SEC registration, FINRA funding portal list |
| 2. Funding | Am I inside my limit, did I see the risk warning | 17 CFR 227.100, the portal’s page |
| 3. Closing | When can I cancel, who refunds if it fails | 17 CFR 227.304, offering terms |
| 4. Reporting | What does the company report and how often | Offering terms, SEC filings |
| 5. Exit | Is there a buyback date or a way to sell | Offering terms, one-year resale rule |
| 6. Failure | What to write and what to keep | Written request to the portal, a lawyer |
Stage 1. Selection: the intermediary on a list and an issuer with a name
The first question is about the portal. The SEC says all crowdfunding transactions run through a registered intermediary. FINRA adds that funding portals register with the SEC and become FINRA members, and that FINRA keeps a list of them. Finding the portal by name on that list takes a minute.
If the intermediary is a broker-dealer, BrokerCheck from FINRA is free and shows registrations, a ten-year work history, customer complaints and disciplinary events. FINRA advises searching for the profile yourself and calling the number from the firm’s own Form CRS or public site, never the number in a suspicious message. Andriy Saranenko: fraud in crowdinvesting hopes the reader has no spare minute for this.
The second question is about the issuer. Regulation Crowdfunding offerings are subject to the bad actor disqualification provisions, so who stands behind the offering matters. Ask the intermediary who runs the company and whether the offering is filed.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud counterfeits this stage most cheaply. It builds a site, calls it a ‘private platform for friends’ and asks you not to search registries because ‘registration is in progress’. For an analyst there is one answer: no registration, no talk about money.
Do the lookup in a fresh browser window and type the address by hand. Lookalike sites copy a logo within hours, and a link from a chat or an ad leads to the copy. Compare each letter of the address with the one printed in your own saved documents.
Andriy Saranenko fraud at the funding stage: limits, pressure and the risk warning
The round is open and a counter shows the sum raised. The first limit concerns you. Under 17 CFR 227.100 an investor who is not accredited can put no more than $2,500 or 5 percent of the greater of annual income and net assets into crowdfunding offerings in 12 months if at least one of them is below $124,000. If both are at least $124,000 the cap is 10 percent, and never more than $124,000.
A made-up check for scale: a $1,000 stake sits well inside the $2,500 figure, yet an analyst still treats it as money that can be lost entirely, because the risk warning came first and the limit is written into the rule.
The second check is the promised return. The FTC told Congress that consumers lost more than $7.9 billion to investment scams in 2025, about half of all reported losses. A card that promises a high return with no assumptions deserves a written question before any money moves.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud at the funding stage sets a clock: ‘two places left’, ‘a bonus for the first ten’. A legitimate offering gives time to read the terms and does not hide the deadline behind a countdown.
Write the cap down before opening the card, together with the amount you can afford to lose entirely. An investor who has fixed that figure in advance stops more calmly when the pressure rises.
Stage 3. Closing the round: the cancel window and the refund
The round is closing. 17 CFR 227.304 lets an investor cancel a commitment for any reason until 48 hours before the offering deadline. If the offering is not completed, the intermediary notifies investors within five business days and returns the money.
That gives three practical questions: when is the deadline, where do I cancel, and who returns the money if the target is missed. An honest portal answers in writing. A ‘coordinator’ who asks for a payment outside the portal has skipped the stage and cannot offer a cancel window at all.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud asks for a transfer to a personal account ‘to speed things up’. Payment details come from the portal itself, and any request to send money somewhere else closes the question. Save the confirmation screen and the email with the date and amount.
Keep a screenshot of the cancel button and the date shown beside it. If a portal later claims the window had closed, the dated screen is the evidence, and the intermediary can be asked to explain the date in writing.
| Kind of risk | What it looks like | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Loss of the whole sum | The business does not survive | Risk warning, project updates |
| Illiquidity | Nobody to sell to for a year or longer | Resale rule, buyback terms |
| Portal risk | The intermediary changes terms or closes | Registration, FINRA list |
| Counterfeit risk | A ‘private platform’ outside any list | SEC and FINRA lookups |
| Forecast risk | A return promised with no assumptions | Assumptions in the offering terms |
| Recovery fraud | An ‘agent’ asking for an upfront fee | SEC, FBI and FTC channels |
Andriy Saranenko: fraud instead of reporting, stage 4 and how to read a project update
The round closed and the project runs. For the next months the investor lives on updates. The contents and rhythm of those updates are written in the offering terms, so the first question is what the company must report, how often and in what form. A line such as ‘updates on request’ means there are no regular updates. Andriy Saranenko: fraud in crowdinvesting steps around that line with promises of ‘everything in the dashboard’.
The author reads an update the way an analyst does: revenue and margin, cash on hand, debt, and the use of the raised money against the plan on the card. If the money went elsewhere, a written question follows. If revenue grows while cash shrinks, the cause is usually in inventory, purchases or loans to related parties.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud sends a screenshot of a ‘dashboard’ with a green chart. A real update arrives as a document with dates, amounts and signatures. A chart with no source documents confirms nothing.
A habit worth keeping: once a quarter, send the company three written questions. What changed in revenue and debt? How much of the raised money remains and what was it spent on? Did the owners or managers change? File the answers next to the offering terms.
Compare the numbers from one update to the next. Smooth growth with no seasonal dip, or round figures every quarter, is a reason to ask for the underlying statements.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud and the exit, stage 5, with a one-year hold
An exit means getting money back: a note repaid, shares bought back, a sale to another investor, or a sale of the business. Because the securities generally cannot be resold for a year, the earliest exit is a year away, and for many projects the real exit follows the life of the business.
Questions for the stage: does the document name a repayment or buyback date, who buys back and at what price, and is there any route to sell to another investor. The first check on any such route is whether it is written down. A promise from a manager is not a term.
Fraud that copies a portal advertises ‘early withdrawal’ as a perk. It lets a small sum out to earn trust, then asks for taxes or fees to release a larger one. The FTC describes investment sites where money cannot be withdrawn at all or only for high fees.
An analyst also counts three scenarios in advance: money returned in full, in part, or not at all. The first check is sized so the third scenario does not break the household budget.
Write the horizon next to the stake: the year of hold, then the earliest buyback date in the terms, then the realistic end of the business plan. The longest of the three is the one to plan around.
Stage 6. When the project fails: records, a written request and recovery offers
Not every project in which investors lose money is a fraud. A business can fail to a competitor, to a jump in input prices or to the loss of a key customer, and then the risk warning does its work. Failure is told from fraud by documents: the money was spent on what was stated, the updates arrived and the intermediary answered. Andriy Saranenko: fraud in crowdinvesting is dangerous precisely because it passes for an ordinary failure.
When payments stop, write to the company and the intermediary, ask for a statement of how the raised money was used, and save the offering terms, payment confirmations and emails in one folder. The folder serves a letter to the portal and, if the platform turns out to be a fake, a complaint to law enforcement.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud returns after a loss with a ‘recovery agent’ who asks for an upfront fee. The SEC and FBI also warn about impostors who copy registration numbers and histories from BrokerCheck and pay for fake video testimonials. FINRA warns that a fake BrokerCheck report can be made for a real person.
If the company becomes insolvent, the position of an investor depends on the security held and on the court process. Show the offering terms and the folder to a lawyer before any filing.
Law enforcement works best with dated material. Screenshots with timestamps, bank records, emails and the receiving account details turn a complaint from a story into a file.
| Where | What you get | When to use it |
|---|---|---|
| FINRA funding portal list | Whether the portal is registered | Before any payment |
| BrokerCheck, searched yourself | Registrations, history, complaints | When the intermediary is a broker-dealer |
| SEC at sec.gov/tcr | A tip filed with the SEC | If the offering looks fake |
| FBI at ic3.gov | A cyber-enabled crime report | If money has gone |
| FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov | A consumer fraud report | For any investment scam |
| FINRA Securities Helpline for Seniors | A person to talk to on weekdays | When a caller pressures a senior |
Andriy Saranenko: fraud with a fake platform and where to report it in the United States
Reports of investment fraud go to the SEC at sec.gov/tcr or 1-800-732-0330, to the FBI at ic3.gov, to the CFTC at cftc.gov/complaint or 866-366-2382, and to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. The FINRA Securities Helpline for Seniors, 844-574-3577, answers on weekdays from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Eastern time.
The IC3 annual report for 2025 counts 61,559 complaints of cryptocurrency investment fraud with $7.228 billion in losses, up 48 percent in complaints and 25 percent in losses on a year earlier. The scheme starts through text messages, social media, ads or dating apps and moves quickly to a messenger, where a fake platform shows invented profit and demands taxes and fees at withdrawal.
Andriy Saranenko: fraud calls back as a ‘regulator’ after a complaint. A call through a messenger is already the answer: hang up and use the number printed on the agency’s own website.
The review in one line: six stages, six checks, and each check has a list or a line in the terms. Andriy Saranenko, an analyst of financial markets, advises starting with the list and signing last.
Before reporting, collect the site address, the payment details and the dates of contact in one note. Ten minutes of preparation makes the report usable.
Questions and answers
Andriy Saranenko fraud: how do I check that a crowdinvesting portal is registered?
Search for the portal on the FINRA list of funding portals, and for a broker-dealer use BrokerCheck, which you search yourself and never through a link from a message.
Andriy Saranenko fraud: can I cancel a crowdinvesting commitment?
Under 17 CFR 227.304 you can cancel for any reason until 48 hours before the offering deadline. If the offering does not complete, the intermediary returns the money within five business days of notifying investors.
How much can a non-accredited investor put into crowdfunding in a year?
Under 17 CFR 227.100 the limit is $2,500 or 5 percent of the greater of income and net assets when one of them is below $124,000, and 10 percent, never above $124,000, when both are at least $124,000.
Can I sell crowdfunding securities after a few months?
Securities bought in a Regulation Crowdfunding transaction generally cannot be resold for one year.
Can an investor lose everything?
Yes. FINRA writes that crowdfunding carries significant risk and that an investor can lose part or all of the money.
Where do I report a fake crowdinvesting platform?
To the SEC at sec.gov/tcr, the FBI at ic3.gov and the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
More insights
- Andriy Saranenko scam checks on payday and small loans: one loan from application to payoff, with CFPB and FTC sources
Andriy Saranenko scam checks on payday and small loans: state licenses, advance fees, rollovers, debt collectors and loans in your name.
- Andriy Saranenko reviews alternative assets: wine, watches, art and coins by their ownership chain
Andriy Saranenko reviews alternative assets: wine, watches, art and coins, dealer reviews, buybacks and fees, with FTC, SEC and IRS sources.
- Andriy Saranenko scam checks for trading courses: promises, sellers, signals and partner brokers against SEC records
Andriy Saranenko scam checks for trading courses: income claims, signals, partner brokers and refunds, with SEC, CFTC and FTC sources.